The first piece of real-hardware work, and it is three bugs that QEMU cannot
show you. The report was an ASUS laptop -- Ryzen 7000-series APU, Radeon
integrated, RTX discrete -- booting to a white underscore on a black screen,
and unable to be offered 1920x1080.
**The framebuffer address was truncated.** The loader handed over
`(UINT32)gop->Mode->FrameBufferBase` and the kernel read a 32-bit field out of
a VBE mode-info block -- a *BIOS* structure the UEFI path had been filling in
because the kernel already knew how to read one. A machine that puts its
aperture above 4 GB, which is ordinary on a laptop with a discrete GPU, got a
plausible-looking address pointing at nothing. The splash went into it, the
kernel was handed it, and the firmware's own cursor kept blinking on an
otherwise black screen. Every step in that sequence succeeded on a number that
was wrong, which is why there is no error message anywhere in it.
SCHBOOT_FB_BASE is the loader's own display block: 64-bit address, 64-bit
size, 32-bit width, height and stride, and the pixel format. The VBE block is
still written for the BIOS loader, but anything that does not fit is left at
zero rather than wrapped -- a truncated address is this bug, and a zero is at
least honest.
The kernel then has a problem the loader does not: its direct map covers the
low 4 GB, so a framebuffer above it needs ioremap(), which needs kpdpt, which
kvmalloc() has not allocated when the early console starts. A low framebuffer
is attached exactly as before; a high one is attached immediately after
kvmalloc(), still thousands of lines before anything else.
**There was more than one adapter, and the first one was taken.**
LocateProtocol answers with *a* GOP and the specification says nothing about
which. QEMU with a stdvga and a virtio-gpu has **three** handles and two of
them are Blt-only with a framebuffer address of zero -- so this is not a
hardware-only hazard, it was a one-in-three chance of drawing into address 0
that happened to keep coming up heads. Every handle is scored now: no
aperture, no candidacy; a readable current mode beats one that needs changing;
size breaks the tie.
**mode_usable() rejected modes real machines have.** A padded scanline (every
GPU that aligns its rows -- and very likely the reason 1920x1080 could not be
offered), a width not divisible by eight (1366x768, which is half the laptops
in the world), and anything below 800x600 (the only mode some firmware gives
over a KVM). All three passed on QEMU, which is why they survived. The mode
list now offers 1366x768 and 640x480 where it did not.
The loader also prints what it found, to the firmware's text console, which is
cleared before the splash: invisible on a boot that works, and the only thing
on the screen on a boot that dies before the splash.
One process note, recorded because it cost a wrong test: `make UEFI_KEEP=1`
ships the loader that is already built. Its own comment says "a build that
quietly ships a stale bootloader is how you spend an evening debugging code
that is not running", and that is exactly what happened -- a regression run
that looked clean had tested the old loader. Loader work gets a full build.
Both supported configurations verified after a clean build: one boot each, no
traps, no panics, socktest and memfdtest green, and the adapter report shows
the right one being chosen out of three.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate 0's last item, "delete the cell grid" -- done as far as it should be, and
the rest of it retired, which is the part worth explaining.
include/text.h made the case against the grid in four charges: it cannot do
variable-width glyphs, cannot position text off a multiple of eight, cannot
anti-alias, and cannot hold a codepoint above 255. Every one of those was
about the *drawing layer*, and every one is now false -- glyphs carry metrics,
PSOGM positions text at arbitrary pixels, the TrueType path blends 8-bit
coverage, and vtcell.ch is a uint32.
What is left is a grid in vt.c, and deleting that would not modernise the
console; it would stop it being a terminal. VT100 escapes address columns,
TIOCGWINSZ reports rows and columns, and every program that draws a box
assumes both. So the item is checked with its remainder rewritten to say what
was actually wrong, rather than ticked as if the original wording had been
carried out.
**What was actually wrong was the duplicate.** gfx.c walked font_data and
blitted glyphs its own way; text.c did the same job into a struct surface, for
no caller but a sysrq self-test. Two implementations of bearings, coverage and
clipping, which had to agree about a cell size only one of them was told had
changed -- and they did not agree, which is why every line of PSOGM once drew
the next character's bitmap underneath itself.
There is one now, and the mechanism is the pleasing part: the console hands
text_draw_glyph() **the cell as a surface of its own** -- same pixels, same
stride, origin moved and bounds set to that cell. Clipping a tall ascender to
its line is then the same bounds check that clips to the edge of a screen, and
there is no second notion of clipping in the tree. `surface_sub()` is six
lines and replaced fourteen of hand-written comparisons.
The bitmap is reached through font_builtin() like any other provider, so the
early console and the real one are one path with different metrics, and the
`if (!cfont)` branch that walked the array is gone. gfx.c no longer includes
font.h; text.c does, being the only file left that reads it -- which also
retires the note in text.c explaining why it could not.
struct surface gained a bpp, because gfx_draw_pixel handles 16, 24 and 32 and
whatever replaces it has to as well. Zero means 32: a UEFI GOP has no other
format and the loader publishes 32 unconditionally, so callers that do not
care say nothing.
One behaviour change, and it is the documented one: a codepoint the font
cannot draw is now a substituted glyph rather than a blank cell. text.h argues
for that directly -- "a missing glyph that draws nothing makes text silently
shorter and the fault impossible to see".
Verified by screendump: the console renders correctly, PSOGM renders
correctly, and `echo t > /proc/sysrq` still draws its specimen through the
surface path with the back buffer at 32bpp. Both supported configurations: one
boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and memfdtest green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate 0's last-but-one open item. Drop a TrueType file at \schos\console.ttf on
the ESP and the console is drawn with it; with no file, the face linked into
the kernel image, which is what an early panic needs and is not a degraded
mode.
**The loader reads it, and that is the decision worth writing down.** The
kernel opening the file once the root filesystem is mounted is the obvious
design. It is also wrong: the console has been drawing since the kernel's
first line, so a font arriving later changes the cell size, which changes the
column count, which re-lays out every terminal -- and blanks them. The kernel
log would vanish off the screen at the moment the root filesystem mounted,
which is exactly the log a machine being brought up for the first time is
being read for. Since the next thing on the list is real hardware, losing that
was not a trade worth making.
So the choice happens before anything is drawn. Three details make it cheap:
- **EfiReservedMemoryType**, not EfiLoaderData. The E820 handoff turns
loader data into usable memory, on the argument that the loader's own
pages are the kernel's the moment it runs -- true of the loader, not true
of a buffer it wants the kernel to keep reading from.
- **Below 4 GB**, because the kernel reaches this through its direct map and
that is how far the direct map goes. A font above it would need an ioremap
the console cannot do before there is a console.
- **Used in place.** No copy, which matters because the kernel has no
contiguous allocator to copy 112 KB into -- the only one is the DMA arena,
and that belongs to devices.
Sized without EFI_FILE_INFO and its GUID: seek past the end and ask where that
landed, which the specification requires to clamp.
Every failure falls back and keeps going -- no file, implausible size, no
memory, short read, unparseable file. The last says so in the log, because a
font that silently did not load looks exactly like a font that did.
Verified by booting with JetBrainsMono-ExtraBold.ttf on the ESP and
screendumping the console: visibly the bold face, against the Regular of a
boot with no file. Three boots each way, no traps and no panics, socktest and
memfdtest green in all six.
Nothing ships a console.ttf: the file would be the file already in the kernel,
and two copies of a font are two things that can disagree.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Eleven cards in a grid is a list people stop reading somewhere around the
fourth one. A row you move through is one you go along, and the section is a
survey rather than a comparison -- nothing in it needs to be read beside
anything else, which is the test for whether a grid was carrying information
or just filling space.
So it is a `.nv-scroller`: snapping, hidden scrollbar, arrows that appear only
at the end that has something behind it, and an edge fade that says "more this
way" without a scrollbar having to. All of that is the component's.
**This site's part is one declaration.** `--nv-scroller-item: 21rem`, because
18rem is a width for a card carrying a line and these carry a paragraph. I had
also written `align-self: stretch` to make the heights match, then checked:
they already do, because a flex row stretches by default. The rule came back
out -- restating something the system already guarantees is exactly the drift
the split between Niveus and `app.css` exists to prevent.
The honest cost: a reader who does not scroll sees three cards rather than
eleven, and the section's own claim ("every card marked runs is in the tree")
is about all of them. The fade and the arrows are what pay for that, and they
are the reason this is a scroller rather than a row with a scrollbar.
Verified in a browser: 11 items, equal 256px heights with no rule of ours,
`data-nv-at-start` set and `data-nv-at-end` clear on load, and the arrows page
the rail and swap over as it reaches each end.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Niveus is the interface language the project uses from here on -- this site
first, applications after it. Rebuilding the site on it is what proves the
system is one, rather than a folder of CSS with a README.
**`style.css` is gone.** 21 KB that transcribed include/theme.h by hand:
palette, type scale, shadows, spacing, every component. The intent was right --
"a site describing an operating system should look like the operating system"
-- and the mechanism was a copy, which means two files that have to be kept in
step by remembering to. What replaced it is `app.css`, which is layout and
nothing else, and one declaration in each page:
:root { --nv-brand: #7C5CFF; }
That is SCH_ACCENT. Niveus derives the accent and its states, the link colour,
the focus ring, the tint in the greys and how far the status colours lean, for
light and dark both. One number to keep true instead of forty.
**The site is now adaptive.** Dark by default, because the OS is dark, with a
Light/Dark/Auto group in the bar that is real. The choice is kept in
localStorage and re-applied by an inline script before first paint, so the page
never renders in one appearance and corrects itself while you watch.
**PSOGM keeps its one purple, and now says so structurally.** #4B1D9A is
spelled the way Niveus spells a subtree with its own colour -- `data-nv-brand`
with its own `--nv-brand` on that section -- so every role inside re-derives
from it rather than being painted on. Still exactly one place, which is what
branding/README.md asks for.
Content is unchanged; what changed is what it is made of. Cards are `.nv-card`,
tags are `.nv-badge`, the support table is `.nv-table`, the crash section is a
`.nv-bed`, and the docs reader's two rails are `.nv-nav--vertical` with the
current document marked by `aria-current` rather than a class of our own.
`docs.js` emits `.nv-table` and `.nv-code`, so a change to the system reaches
the documentation too.
Three things were found by looking at it in a browser rather than by reading
it, and all three are the same mistake: **a `.nv-card` carries no padding of
its own -- its parts do.** The stat tiles, the "One ISO, one stick" band and
the card headers were all built from bare children, so numbers ran to the card
edge, the USB mark hung off it, and a title and its badge sat at opposite ends
of a row meant for a title and a trailing slot. Where the component had a right
way to say it, the markup now says it that way; where it did not -- a tile has
no parts -- `app.css` supplies the padding and says why.
Checked: every nv- class used across the three pages and docs.js exists in the
CSS, every token referenced by app.css is defined, and app.css contains no hex
value at all. Niveus's own tools/check.py passes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two things.
**The F8 resolution now applies to the other displays as well.** It already
reached them once vgpud started -- that was the last commit but one -- but not
before: choosing 1024x768 changed the screen it was chosen on and left the
other at 1280x800, so the menu and then the splash appeared on it as a small
rectangle in the middle of a larger black one. Which is a fair reading of "the
resolution change is not changing resolution".
The resolution offered in that menu is a statement about the machine's display,
not about one adapter of it, so both stages before vgpud now follow it:
the loader mirrors_match() puts every mirror GOP into the primary's mode,
called from mirrors_show() so it cannot be forgotten at a new
call site. Two integer comparisons in the common case.
the kernel setup_scanout() takes gfx's dimensions over GET_DISPLAY_INFO's.
Same argument as vgpud's bring_up(): the host window's size is
a fact about QEMU, and the console's mode is the one somebody
chose.
**And the greeting is no longer a race.** "Welcome to SchOS!" was printed after
every job had been started, including the shell on the console -- so which of
the two reached the screen first was up to the scheduler, and it went both ways
about evenly. A boot that sometimes greets you above the prompt and sometimes
below it does not read as two orderings of one boot; it reads as a line printed
by mistake.
schinitd now holds back the job that owns the console -- `own_tty`, which is
exactly the job whose output lands there -- until after the greeting is
written. That is enough to settle it: this process writes the line, and only
then asks PID 1 to spawn the shell, so the fork has not happened yet. Nothing
waits on it that was not already waiting.
Verified: F8 -> Resolution -> 1024x768 -> boot, with the virtio head
screendumped over QMP at three points during startup and once at the prompt --
1024x768 throughout, and byte-identical to the stdvga head. Three consecutive
boots put the greeting at the same offset, ahead of the prompt every time.
Both supported configurations: one boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and
memfdtest green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two things, both asked for.
**The crash report no longer says which monitors it reached.** "The report is
on the virtio-gpu display too" was a line about the crash screen printed on the
crash screen. The report says what happened and where to read it again; that is
not part of it.
**And the second head now shows the F8 menu and the boot.** It used to be black
until vgpud started several seconds into userspace -- through the splash,
through the menu, through every boot message -- which from the outside is
indistinguishable from a display that does not work. Three stages now cover the
whole boot and hand over to each other without coordinating:
*The loader.* LocateProtocol() answers with the first GOP and offers no way to
ask for the rest, so the rest are found by handle and fed the primary's
framebuffer as a Blt source at the points where a screen is finished: the menu,
the resolution chooser, system information, the splash, each segment of the
kernel load. Blt rather than a second framebuffer to draw into, because a
virtio GOP does not have one -- the same fact that made a virtio-only machine
reboot-loop two commits ago.
*The kernel.* gfx remembers which rows were drawn, as one span rather than a
list of rectangles, because console output is lines and a span is what lines
make. display_mirror_console() copies that span across: a line of boot text is
one cell-row transfer, not a screen. Primed once after pci_init(), because a
display that has just appeared has a black scanout and the console it should be
showing was drawn by the loader into a framebuffer it knows nothing about.
*Then vgpud*, from the same console framebuffer, unchanged.
**Two bugs found building it, both worth the retelling.**
The mirror ran per character from inside vt_feed -- which is inside the console
lock -- and vga_disp_acquire() announces its back buffer with a cprintf. A CPU
taking a lock it already holds, with a call chain that said exactly that. It
runs at the end of consolewrite() and cprintf() now, outside the lock, which is
also the better batching: one transfer per write instead of one per character.
And "is this the console's own screen" was asked of the pointer acquire()
returned. vga_fb hands back a back buffer it copies onto the console's
framebuffer afterwards, so on a one-screen machine the answer was "a different
screen" -- and the console was mirrored onto itself through two megabytes of
intermediate, allocated for the purpose. display_ops grew scanout_phys, which
is a fact about the hardware rather than a policy a driver can get subtly
wrong, and it is asked first: it has no side effects and acquire() has two.
Verified with two heads under QEMU, screendumping the virtio head every 400 ms
from power-on: splash, splash, splash, then the console, and it stays. The F8
menu appears on it; choosing 1024x768 there brings both heads up at 1024x768
byte-identical. A panic still reaches both. Both supported configurations: one
boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and memfdtest green.
One gap remains and is documented rather than hidden: while the kernel's driver
resets the device during probe, QEMU shows "Display output is not active" for a
fraction of a second. A device being taken over has no scanout until the new
driver sets one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
"it also doesn't show crash screen on virtio gpu or just other gpu than default
vga" -- true, and on the virtio-gpu it was worse than nothing. The head kept
showing the console from a second before the panic: one screen saying the
kernel is dead, the other showing a shell prompt.
panic() painted into the console framebuffer and stopped there. Two cases were
missing, and they are not the same problem.
**The kernel still drives it.** display_acquire() hands back a buffer; the
report is copied in and presented. Ordinary, and a no-op when the display
class's buffer *is* the console's, so a one-screen machine does not do the work
twice.
**A process drives it.** The hard one, and the one hybrid.md owed an answer
for. The kernel let go of the device deliberately, and the process holding it
will never run again -- there is no scheduling after a panic -- so there is
nobody left to ask. It is not a race that can be won by being careful.
So the userspace driver says where it is scanning out *in advance*:
PCIIOC_PANICFB, registered by vgpud after bring-up and after every modeset. On
a panic the kernel paints the report into that memory and asks the kernel
driver the device was taken from to put it on screen one last time --
`panic_present` in struct pci_driver, which virtio-gpu implements by resetting
the device out from under a driver that is still nominally running. That is
safe here and nowhere else, because nothing is going to run again.
The panic path allocates nothing. It cannot: a corrupted heap is one of the
ways a machine gets here, and an allocator that deadlocks takes the crash
screen *and* the serial log's last chance to be read. So the driver keeps its
BAR mappings across the handover, rebuilds one queue from 20 KB of static
memory, and bounds every spin -- including the reset acknowledge, which is an
unbounded `while` in probe() and correct there.
**The registration is checked like the promise it is.** The range must lie
inside a block that process got from PCIIOC_DMA on that device. Without that,
a claimed device would be a way to nominate any physical address in the machine
-- page tables, kernel text -- to be overwritten with four megabytes of crash
report at the one moment nothing is left to notice. That is a worse bug than
the one this fixes. It goes away with the claim and with the process.
What it buys is worth stating plainly: a device can be evicted to userspace
without the kernel losing its ability to tell you the machine died. The
alternative was a driver boundary that is also a blind spot.
Verified both ways under QEMU with two heads, `echo c > /proc/sysrq`, and a
screendump of each over QMP:
vgpud holding the device both heads byte-identical, serial says
"The report is on the virtio-gpu display too."
kernel holding it same, via display_acquire/display_present
(/proc/pci shows 1af4:1050 [virtio-gpu])
Both supported configurations: one boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and
memfdtest green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
"virtio gpu doesn't follow f8 menu default resolution" -- it did not, and now
that the head mirrors the console that is visible rather than academic.
vgpud sized itself from GET_DISPLAY_INFO, which answers with the size of the
*host's window*: a number set by dragging a corner, that says nothing about the
machine and everything about QEMU. Meanwhile the resolution the F8 menu offered
at boot is the one that was actually chosen, and it is the console's.
So picking 1024x768 at the menu gave a second display still at 1280x800, with
the console letterboxed inside it on the theme ground -- the right pixels in
the wrong mode, on a display that could simply have been the right size.
console_open() now runs *before* bring_up(), and bring_up() takes the console's
mode when there is a console. That ordering is the whole fix and it is not
cosmetic: the DMA allocation is sized from those numbers and fixed for the life
of the process, so a mode chosen after the fact could only ever be smaller than
the window already paid for. A machine with no console to mirror brings up
whatever the device reports, exactly as before.
Verified by driving the F8 menu over the serial line -- 'o', Resolution,
1024x768, boot -- and screendumping both heads over QMP: both come up 1024x768
and are byte-identical, where the virtio head used to stay 1280x800. `schmode
1024 768` from a 1280x800 boot still works. Both supported configurations: one
boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and memfdtest green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
"but Virtio GPU is still non functional. it only shows logo" -- and that was
a fair reading of it. A second monitor showing a mark for ever is
indistinguishable from a second monitor that does not work.
The mark was the right answer to the question hybrid.md asked: H2 and H3 needed
a screenshot that proved a *userspace process* had drawn something, and that
the driver came back after being killed. Both are closed. What was left was a
display whose entire output was a logo, on a machine whose console was sitting
on the other head.
So vgpud mirrors the console onto it.
**A copy with a diff.** /dev/fb0 maps the console's framebuffer; the virtio
backing store is already mapped, because vgpud allocated it. The backing
therefore holds, at all times, exactly what was last sent to the device --
which means it *is* the previous frame, and "what changed" needs no third
buffer. Ten times a second: compare rows, skip the ones that match, copy the
ones that do not, transfer the one rectangle spanning the rows that changed.
Hence present() becoming present_rect(). Moving one line of text through a
full-screen transfer of a 1280x800 resource is most of a megabyte of copy for
a few hundred bytes of difference, and this loop runs whether or not anything
is happening.
Mapping /dev/fb0 does not take the screen from the console: the pages are the
ones the console draws into, and fb_mapped() only arranges a redraw when the fd
is closed. This one never is.
Sizes differ, so a head larger than the console centres it on the theme ground
the mark already draws, and a smaller head shows the top-left corner -- which
is where a terminal puts everything worth seeing. Scaling is the alternative
and it is the wrong one; text resampled to a non-integer ratio is text you
cannot read. The blocking accept() became poll() with the frame interval as its
timeout, because holding the device is no longer the only thing to do.
Not the endpoint: a compositor will want this head for itself, and when there
is one this goes away. Until then the honest thing for a working display to
show is the system that is running on it.
**And a bug older than any of it.** schmode reported "cannot reach vgpud on
/run/vgpud -- it is not running" about a process that was running perfectly
well. Every boot after the first, on any image whose root is writable, and
nothing to do with this change -- it reproduces on the previous commit, 3 runs
in 4.
bind() creates a node at the path, and /run is a directory on the root
filesystem rather than a tmpfs. The node outlived the process that bound it and
the boot it was bound in, so the next boot's vgpud claimed the device, drew,
held it -- and then failed bind() on a name that already existed. A driver
nobody could talk to, and an error message naming the wrong cause.
It unlinks before binding now, which is what a Unix daemon does. The usual
objection, that this lets a second instance steal a live socket, does not apply
here: two vgpuds cannot coexist, because the first holds the PCI claim and the
second is refused the device long before it reaches bind(). The claim is the
mutual exclusion; the socket node never was.
Verified by screendumping both heads over QMP: with the console at 1280x800 the
two are byte-identical, and after `schmode 1024 768` the virtio head carries
the console at the new mode. Three consecutive boots of one image all reach a
working control socket, where the previous commit managed one. Both supported
configurations: one boot each, no traps, no panics, socktest and memfdtest
green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Booting with a virtio-gpu as the *only* display reboot-looped. Not a hang, not
a panic: the firmware came back round to the boot menu, started the loader
again, and did it again, for ever, with nothing to say why.
virtio-gpu has no linear aperture, so OVMF's virtio GOP implements Blt and
nothing else. On a machine with one and nothing else, the firmware reports a
width and a height and a FrameBufferBase of **zero**:
schos: framebuffer 0x0000000000000000 0x500x0x320
Two places took that at face value.
**kmain() tested `if (bi.ptr && ...)` with bi.ptr already run through P2V()**,
and P2V(0) is KERNBASE, which is not zero. So the guard could not fail -- and
its own comment, three lines above, said "drawing into address zero is a worse
failure than staying quiet". The intent was exactly right and the test could
never enforce it. It reads the physical value first now and tests that.
**vga_fb_init() attached the scanout regardless**, one layer down, so fixing
kmain alone just moved the same write.
Either one had gfx_clear() write four megabytes over physical 0: the real-mode
IVT, the BIOS data area, the AP trampoline at 0x7000, the early page tables.
Hence a reset with no output -- there was nothing left to run.
Both refuse now, and the refusal says what it is:
vga: firmware reported a 1280x800 display with no framebuffer address;
no graphical console
A machine with no usable linear framebuffer gets no graphical console. That is
the truth about it, and the serial line still has everything.
**It still does not reach a shell on such a machine**, and that is recorded
rather than implied: the console path assumes a framebuffer -- vt_init()
reports a terminal of `0 by 0` cells -- and that path has never been exercised.
What this fixes is a machine that destroyed low memory and reset; what it does
not do is make a headless boot work. Supported remains stdvga, with virtio-gpu
optional beside it, which is what docs/architecture/graphics.md already said.
Both supported configurations verified: stdvga alone and stdvga with
virtio-gpu, one boot each, no traps, socktest and memfdtest green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The three F8 screens painted into the framebuffer and nowhere else. That is
right on a machine with a screen and useless on one driven over a serial cable
-- which is how this loader is usually driven, and which f8_window() already
went out of its way to support: it accepts 'o' as well as F8 because, in its
own words, "a serial console sends no scan codes at all".
So the prompt invited a serial user in, drew them a menu they could not see,
and then blocked for ever on a key they had no way to choose. The whole visible
behaviour was:
Press F8 for boot options...
<nothing, for ever>
Each screen echoes itself to COM1 now -- the boot menu, the resolution list and
System Information. The whole thing once on entry, then one line per *move*;
not on every keypress, because a serial terminal has no cursor to paint over
and an unrecognised key would scroll the selection past again for nothing.
Straight to COM1 rather than through print(): print() goes to ConOut until the
splash is up, and ConOut on a machine with graphics draws its text across the
menu that was just painted there.
Two details found by actually driving it, neither cosmetic:
- **The item number is shown only where it is a key you can press.** The boot
menu takes 1-5. The resolution list takes only W/S and Enter and is longer
than nine entries, so numbering it printed ':', ';', '<' past the ninth --
a character nobody can type, offering to select something.
- **Q goes back as well as Esc.** A lone ESC byte on a serial line is
indistinguishable from the start of an escape sequence, so the terminal
driver holds it back waiting for the rest and it never arrives as a key.
Esc is the obvious thing to press on a screen and unreachable on a cable --
the same shape of problem as F8, and the same answer.
Driven end to end over serial: open the menu, walk it with W/S, open System
Information and come back, open Resolution and come back with Q, then boot.
The graphical menu is unchanged apart from the hint now naming Q.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two reports, and the first one was not an F8 bug at all.
**Choosing "Boot SchOS (verbose)" appeared to do nothing.** The menu worked,
the flag crossed, and the kernel really did boot verbose -- and then the
machine *reset* partway through and the second boot was quiet. So what anybody
ended up looking at was an ordinary boot, which reads as "verbose is broken".
PROBE before startothers, ncpu=2 <- verbose boot
SchOS UEFI loader <- the firmware, again
PROBE before startothers, ncpu=2 <- quiet boot
PROBE after startothers
mpmain() opened with
kinfo("cpu%d: starting\n", cpunum());
enable_sse();
idtinit();
and the order is the bug. enable_sse() clears CR0.EM; until it runs, *any* SSE
instruction on that CPU faults, and the kernel is not built with -mno-sse, so
the compiler emits them freely for struct copies and inline memset. idtinit()
loads that CPU's IDT; until it runs there is nowhere for a fault to go. So the
#UD is not a panic -- it is a double fault with no handler, then a triple
fault, then the firmware comes back up. A triple fault prints nothing, which is
why there was no last line to go on.
**Why only on a verbose boot**, which is what disguised it as an F8 problem:
kinfo() is log-only when the boot is quiet, so the work is a few bytes into a
ring and no XMM is involved. A verbose boot renders that same line through the
TrueType rasteriser, and that is where the SSE lands.
Setup first, announcement second. The general rule, stated where the next
person will meet it: a processor announces that it is up after it is able to
run, not before.
Verbose now boots once and puts the whole log on the screen -- `verbose boot:`
lines, `cpu1: starting`, the mount, `schinit: ready`, the jobs starting -- which
is what F8 was for and what a machine with no serial port needs.
**And vgpud drew a test card.** Three colour bands, four gradients, a
checkerboard, and the driver's own pid in binary along the bottom edge. That
was scaffolding for hybrid.md's H2 and H3: a screenshot had to answer "did a
*userspace process* put this here", and "did the driver come back" needed a
restarted instance to look different from one that never stopped. Both
milestones closed a while ago and the test card stayed, so a second display
showed something garish with nothing to explain it.
It draws the Shift mark on SCH_BG now, from the same include/logo.h the loader
splash and the kernel console use. That answers the same question a black
screen cannot -- something is driving this device -- as the system rather than
as a test rig.
Also: vgpud's "no control socket" line is vputs, not puts. It is progress, not
news, and it was printing on the console of every quiet boot.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate 1, item 3, and the last of foundations.md.
bind() creates a T_SOCK node at the path; connect() resolves the path and looks
for the socket bound to **that inode**. Matching on the inode rather than on
the path *string* is the part that matters: the name used to live only in the
socket table, so two spellings of one path missed each other, a relative path
never matched an absolute one, and there was nothing to stat() or unlink().
An inode is the thing a path resolves *to*, so connect() can walk the path
however it likes and arrive at the same socket.
# ls -l /tmp
srwxr-xr-x 1 root root 0 2026-09-22 08:04 socktest
The node is a marker, not the binding. It holds no data and the live
association stays in the socket table, so a socket file left by a crash is
what Linux leaves behind -- a dead file that connect() refuses until something
binds again -- and unlink()ing a live socket's path does not disturb anyone
already connected.
EADDRINUSE comes from the *directory* rather than from a scan of the table,
deliberately: a stale socket file has to refuse a rebind for the same reason a
running server's does, or two servers both believe they own it. The creation
lives in sys_bind() and not in unix.c, because that is the layer with both --
kernel/net/unix.c knows about sockets and has no business calling create().
T_SOCK is a compat addition to SchFS by the rule in schfs.h: a driver that does
not know SCHFS_T_SOCK maps it to a zero-length regular file, so nothing goes
stale and nothing becomes unreadable.
cmd/socktest section 15 asserts the plan's own wording -- bind, stat, see an
`s`, unlink -- plus the two a name table could never fail: a second bind to a
live path is refused, and connecting to a path that is a *regular file* is
refused rather than matched by name.
**And the semantics being real broke socktest on its second run**, correctly:
the socket files persisted and every bind() hit EADDRINUSE. Every real server
unlinks before binding; socktest now does too, which is the change the new
behaviour demands rather than a workaround for it.
Chasing that turned up something worse. `socktest` reported rc=1 with every
check passing, and so did every other first-party program:
- **lib/start.S called main and threw %eax away.** sys_exit() reads the
status from %rdi and nothing put it there, so every program exited with
whatever that register happened to hold. Every test suite ends in
`return failures ? 1 : 0` and none of it reached the shell.
- **exit(void) passed no status either**, for the same reason: the
declaration takes no argument, so %rdi was the caller's litter.
`if socktest; then` works now, and a failing command reports 1 -- checked both
ways, because a fix that makes everything return 0 would look identical from
the success side.
Also factored: unlink_path() out of sys_unlink, so a failed bind can take its
own node back out without going through the syscall entry, and create_sock()
as a named door rather than exporting create() with an arbitrary type.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate 1, item 2, and the thing a Wayland buffer crosses on.
memfd_create(2) is the same segment machinery shmget() already had -- pages,
refcounts, no_free VMAs, the fork and exit accounting -- reached by
**descriptor** rather than by System V key. That difference is the entire
point and the reason it exists on Linux at all: two processes share memory by
passing the fd over a socket, so neither has to agree on a path or race to
invent a key. It is also why SCM_RIGHTS had to be item 1.
docs/plan/foundations.md proposed exactly this and it was right: what memfd
adds on top of shmget is a segment that starts empty and is sized by
ftruncate(), and a file that owns one reference to it. FD_MEMFD, and
read/write/lseek/fstat all learn about it -- a descriptor that refuses read()
is a surprise nobody needs.
Three things are refused rather than faked, each the honest version of
something this kernel cannot do:
- MAP_PRIVATE on a memfd. Every caller is sharing on purpose; a private
mapping of an anonymous object is an expensive MAP_ANONYMOUS.
- Mapping past the end. Linux faults those pages in; there is no handler
here that could.
- Shrinking while mapped. Linux truncates the pages out from under the
mapper; here a freed page would stay mapped to memory somebody else now
owns.
Writable MAP_SHARED of a *real file* is still ENODEV. That needs a page cache,
and an anonymous object has no such contract to break -- which is precisely
why memfd is the narrow answer.
**cmd/memfdtest**, seventeen checks, written so a permissive implementation
cannot pass: an mmap that quietly returned private zeroed pages satisfies every
return code and fails the one assertion that matters, because the reader is a
different process. It ends with the combination the plan singled out -- a memfd
sent over a socketpair to a receiver that closes every inherited copy first,
maps only the descriptor that arrived, reads what the sender wrote and writes
back where the sender can see it.
Two things were found by writing that test, both of which had been refusing
everything that was not FD_INODE:
- sys_fstat() never reached filestat(), so the memfd branch there was
unreachable from the syscall that needs it. It also refused pipes and
sockets, and returned -1 (which musl reads as EPERM) rather than an errno.
- sys_lseek() the same, and SEEK_END needs a length that is not in an inode.
Verified: 40 consecutive runs leave MemFree at exactly the value it started
at -- 936656 kB before and after -- so nothing leaks across creation, dual
mapping, descriptor passing and exit.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate 0's last structural row. kernel/core/kmem.c: slabs are pages from
kalloc() with a header at the front, and free objects hold the free list in
their own first eight bytes.
That last detail is the whole design. **An object carries no header and
freeing performs no search**: the page base of any object *is* its slab, and
the slab names its cache. It is also exactly why an object cannot exceed a
page, which matters below.
Two interfaces. kmem_cache_create/alloc/free for a subsystem with one kind of
thing -- it gets its own line in /proc/slab, which is most of why naming it is
worth the argument -- and kmalloc/kmfree over power-of-two classes from 16 to
2048 for code with no single type to build a cache around. Each cache keeps
partial and full lists; a slab that empties goes straight back to kalloc()
rather than being kept, so /proc/slab never overstates what is held.
`make kmem-test` asserts the bookkeeping on the build machine. Same arrangement
as schfs-objtest, and for the same reason: slab lists, free-list threading, the
page-to-cache lookup and whether pages actually come back are all things that
can be wrong without a kernel to be wrong in. 26 checks, including one that a
permissive allocator cannot pass -- write a distinct pattern through 512
objects and read them all back, because two objects sharing storage shows up
there and nowhere else.
One bug the test found immediately: kmem_max_obj() returned the raw page
remainder, which kmem_cache_create() then rounded *up* past its own limit. The
largest legal size was reported as illegal.
**It does not do what the register said it would.** The claim was that every
fixed table exists to work around kalloc. Measured:
struct proc 10656 NPROC 128 larger than a page
struct socket 4928 NSOCK 32 larger than a page
struct buf 4272 NBUF 256 larger than a page
struct inode 280 NINODE 200 a cache, bounded on purpose
struct device 120 NDEVICE 32 3.8 KB, never hit
struct file 48 NFILE 512 24 KB, never hit
The three largest cannot go in a page-backed slab whatever it does. NINODE is
a cache and is meant to be bounded. NFILE and NDEVICE are small enough that
their tables are rounding errors and their ceilings have never been reached.
Freeing the big ones needs a contiguous multi-page allocator, which is a
different thing and is not written. That is now in the register and in
docs/architecture/kernel.md rather than left as a claim nobody checked.
What it does fix is real, and was measured rather than assumed:
- **A pipe is 640 bytes and came from a whole 4096-byte page.** Every `|` in
a shell command burned three and a half kilobytes it never touched. Six
pipes per page now, and /proc/slab shows the page going back when they
close.
- **procread() built its answer in a 2048-byte array on the kernel stack**,
under a comment that had warned about exactly that since it was written --
it stayed a local because a whole page for 2 KB felt worse, and kmalloc is
the answer that was missing. Its frame is 64 bytes now instead of ~2100.
- procfs's other generator took a page from kalloc for the same 2 KB.
Verified on a boot: /proc/slab tracks pipe and kmalloc-2048 through real
pipelines, allocs and frees balance, and $(), ps, time, readlink, sigtest and
rename are all still green with no traps.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`ps` listed the shell and nothing the shell had started -- background jobs
included, which is how it was noticed.
p->ctty was set by TIOCSCTTY and never inherited, so every child of a shell had
ctty 0. `ps` with no arguments shows only processes on *this* terminal, so a
job running on your terminal was invisible because the only process that had
ever claimed one was the shell itself.
The controlling terminal is a property of the session, not of the process that
happened to call the ioctl. It crosses fork() with pgid and sid, three lines
above where it now sits.
# sleep 60 & ; sleep 61 &
# ps
PID TTY TIME CMD
14 1:11 00:00:00 sleep
9 1:11 00:00:00 zsh
15 1:11 00:00:00 sleep
17 1:11 00:00:00 ps
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Four Gate 0 rows, and a fifth found while checking one of them.
**getrusage() did not distinguish RUSAGE_CHILDREN from RUSAGE_SELF**, which
undersells it: it ignored `who` entirely and reported the machine's *uptime*
as the caller's user time. Every process of every age answered with the same
number. Per-process CPU time is sampled at the timer tick now and split on the
interrupted privilege level; children's time is rolled up in wait() rather than
exit(), because RUSAGE_CHILDREN means *reaped* children and a running one has
not contributed yet.
**And wait4()'s fourth argument is a `struct rusage *` that was read off the
stack and thrown away.** That is the one shells actually use -- wait3() is the
same syscall with pid -1 -- so zsh's `time` reported
16777216.01s user 1073.78s system 927983249% cpu
for every command. 2^24 seconds is uninitialised memory, and it did not vary
with the workload because it was never written. Now:
busy loop 2.66s user 97% cpu 2.720 total
sleep 2 0.02s user 0% cpu 2.248 total
ls -lR / 0.70s user 65% cpu 1.070 total
**ru_stime is a structural zero and says so.** MSR_SFMASK includes FL_IF, so
SYSCALL clears interrupts and no tick can land while a process is inside a
syscall. Tick sampling cannot see kernel time at all here. Charging it needs
TSC deltas closed and reopened around every sched(), which is scheduler
accounting rather than sampling; the limitation is written down in
docs/architecture/kernel.md rather than papered over.
**/proc/<pid>/exe is a symlink.** It also needed a real st_size, and every
other procfs file deliberately reports zero -- readlink(2) bounds its copy by
it, so a symlink of size 0 resolves to the empty string, which looks like it
worked and is worse than the regular file was. Generating that one path in
ilock() costs one small render per stat() of one file.
**OVMF memory reporting is closed**: 1 GB reports 1017 MB usable, 2 GB reports
2041 MB. The firmware keeps about 7 MB either way, which is the right shape.
**And `ps` printed a header and nothing else**, which is not in any list
because nobody had run it. `ps` with no arguments shows only processes on
*this* terminal; /proc/<pid>/stat hardcoded tty_nr to 0, so nothing could ever
match. `ps -e` always worked, which is exactly what hid it. p->ctty was already
tracked -- procfs simply was not asked. Fields 14..17 were hardcoded zero too,
so TIME read 00:00:00 however long a process had run; they carry the new
counters now, and a shell that has burned 653 ticks reports 00:00:06.
Verified: utime climbs 18 -> 653 across a loop in the shell itself, `ps` lists
its own terminal, `ps -e` still lists everything, `readlink /proc/1/exe` gives
/bin/schinit, and sigtest/$()/rename/dmesg are all still green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`#define ROOTDEV 1` -- IDE disk 1 -- so a kernel could only ever root on the
disk it was *built* expecting. Booting the same image from a USB stick was
impossible by construction, and that was the one thing standing between this
kernel and its own acceptance test, which begins "boot on real hardware from a
USB stick".
rootdev_mount() probes. schfs_kmount() was already written for exactly this --
its own comment says "the uberblock scan doubles as the probe: no valid
uberblock means this is simply not a SchFS volume, which is not an error worth
reporting loudly" -- and a failed probe leaves the slot unmounted and reusable,
which is what makes a loop over candidates legal at all. So the change is one
function and one call site; the only real use of ROOTDEV was `schfs_kmount()`.
Order is preference, not confidence: a RAMDISK_ROOT build wins outright, then
USB, then IDE 1, then IDE 0. USB before the fixed disks because a stick that is
plugged in was plugged in on purpose. iderw() panics on an absent drive rather
than failing, so each candidate is checked with ide_disk_present() /
usb_storage_present() first -- which is what those predicates are for.
Verified with **no IDE disk attached at all**: boots, mounts the stick, writes
a file, and the file is still there on the next boot.
[ 0.000021] root: USB disk (device 3)
And when nothing matches, it names what it looked at, because "no root
filesystem" with no list is the least useful thing a kernel can say at the one
moment somebody needs to know which disk it expected:
root: no SchFS volume on any candidate device. Looked at:
device 3, USB disk: not present
device 1, IDE disk 1: not present
device 0, IDE disk 0: present, but no SchFS on it
**That message is also how dmesg turned out to be broken**, because it did not
appear in `dmesg` and should have. `dmesg` printed *nothing at all*, on a
system whose boot banner says "or dmesg once you are in" and whose entire
quiet-boot design is "route the detail into the kernel log and say how to read
it". The log was there the whole time -- `cat /proc/kmsg` has always worked --
but the one command anybody would reach for could not see it.
Two separate faults, each alone enough:
- **sys_syslog() was `return 0`.** dmesg does not read /proc/kmsg; it calls
klogctl(10) for the buffer size and klogctl(3) to read. 0 to the first one
means "the log is zero bytes", and a stub that answers 0 is
indistinguishable from a machine that logged nothing. Implemented for the
actions that mean something here; the rest return -EINVAL rather than 0,
because a console log level this kernel does not have is not a request that
succeeded.
- **With that fixed, dmesg was still empty.** It parses every line with
`sscanf(msg, "<%u>[%llu.%llu] %n", ...)` and silently drops anything that
does not match. The ring's `[ 0.00] text` already matches everything
after the priority -- scanf skips the leading spaces -- so the only missing
thing was the `<6>`. klog_render_syslog() adds it on the way out rather
than storing it: the ring is also what a person reads with `cat
/proc/kmsg` and what PSOGM points at after a crash, and an ABI detail
belongs at the boundary that has the ABI.
Also: the first version of the no-root diagnostic printed
%-11s device 1596400
because cprintf() has no field-width specifier -- it prints "%-11s" literally
and then reads the next argument for the %d. Plain %s now, with the note.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Checking the rest of ZSH_CACHE after the killesrch fix, on the principle that
one wrong answer in a hand-written block is rarely the only one. Two more, both
`yes`, both measurable on the running system in a line each.
**zsh_cv_sys_path_dev_fd=/dev/fd.** Neither /dev/fd nor /proc/self/fd exists --
/proc/self does not exist at all. So `<(cmd)` failed at the point of use with
cat: /dev/fd/11: No such file or directory
which reads as a broken command rather than as a feature the system does not
have.
**zsh_cv_sys_fifo=yes.** mkfifo() does not fail here. It *succeeds*, and
produces a character device: mknod() turns S_IFIFO into a T_DEV and keeps the
major/minor, so `ls -l` shows `crw-rw-rw- 438, 0` where a `p` belongs, and
nothing written to it comes back out. Succeeding wrongly is what made `yes`
look defensible.
Both `no` now. `<(cmd)` says "doesn't look like your system supports FIFOs",
which names the missing thing instead of blaming cat, and `$( )` is unaffected.
The two gaps are recorded in docs/architecture/filesystem.md rather than left
implied by a build flag -- named pipes and a path to one's own descriptors are
both real features, and neither exists.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`X=$(echo hi)` never returned. It has been in docs/history/kernel.md section 7
as "mksh's job control still doesn't reliably progress ... root cause not yet
isolated" with three suspects, and it was none of them, and it was not the
kernel at all.
ports/zsh/Makefile carries a block of `zsh_cv_*` answers for the checks
autoconf cannot run when cross-compiling. One of them was
zsh_cv_sys_killesrch=no
which reads like a reassuring property and is in fact the answer to the
question configure asks: *does kill(pid, 0) return ESRCH correctly?* `no` makes
configure emit BROKEN_KILL_ESRCH, and Src/zsh_system.h answers that with
#ifdef BROKEN_KILL_ESRCH
#undef ESRCH
#define ESRCH EINVAL
#endif
zsh's waitforpid() ends its wait on `errno != ESRCH` (Src/jobs.c:1569). With
ESRCH redefined to EINVAL (22) and the kernel correctly returning ESRCH (3),
that condition was true for ever: the shell sat in sigsuspend waiting for a
child it had already reaped. An instrumented zsh says the whole thing in one
line -- kill returned -1, errno is 3, and the constant it is compared against
is 22:
WFPkill -1 3 22
**Autoconf's own cross-compilation default for that check is `yes`.** Deleting
the line would have been correct. Writing it down as "a fact about SchOS" is
what got it wrong, and the block's comment now says to read each name as the
question rather than as a property.
Verified: `X=$(echo inline)`, `$(/bin/echo external)`, backticks, nested
`$(echo $(echo deep))`, a slow child, and `$(ls /bin | wc -l)` all return.
mksh -- as /bin/sh -- was never affected.
Two corrections to yesterday's note, both confident and both wrong:
- "Not zsh, mksh hangs the same way" was false. mksh installs as /bin/sh,
so that test was a `command not found` whose output scrolled past. Had the
binary been named right, this would have localised to zsh's build in one
step instead of a day.
- cmd/sigtest had already proven the kernel's SIGCHLD/sigsuspend contract,
and a musl-linked probe had already shown kill(pid,0) returning -1 with
errno == ESRCH == 3 and zsh's own loop condition evaluating false. Both
results were right; both were read as "so it must be subtler in the
kernel". What they actually pointed at was the one place the probe and the
shell differed -- how each was compiled.
The lesson is narrow enough to state: when a probe that reproduces a program's
exact syscall sequence behaves correctly and the program does not, stop looking
under the syscalls and look at the build.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Went looking for why `X=$(echo hi)` hangs every shell. Did not find it. Found
two other things, and built the instrument that rules out the largest suspect.
**The signal return trampoline was ABI-blind.** deliver_signals() manufactures
a return address for the handler -- seven bytes on the user stack reading
`mov eax, 15 ; syscall`. Fifteen is *Linux's* rt_sigreturn, which is right for
anything musl-linked, and that is every port and every shell. For a first-party
binary it is native syscall 15, which is `open`. So a handler in any cmd/
program ran, returned into the trampoline, called open() with whatever the
handler had left in its registers, got -ENOENT, and carried on executing the
stack bytes after the trampoline.
pid 14 sigtest: trap 14 err 4 rip 0x46ca7 addr 0xfffffffffffffffe
rax=fffffffffffffffe ... rsp=46ca0
ustack: 46e30 46ca0 50f0000000fb8 0 0 0
rip is rsp+7 -- one past a seven-byte trampoline -- and the third word of the
stack is the trampoline's own bytes. It emits the number for the process's ABI
now; syscall_map is the thing that says which numbering this process speaks.
**SIG_BLOCK, SIG_UNBLOCK and SIG_SETMASK were not defined anywhere.**
sys_sigprocmask branched on bare 0, 1 and 2 with the names in comments, so
anything outside the kernel had to spell the number and hope it had the right
one. Defined in posix.h, used in the kernel.
**cmd/sigtest** asserts the SIGCHLD/sigsuspend contract every shell is built
on, and it is written so a permissive stub cannot pass: a blocked SIGCHLD stays
pending, sigsuspend delivers an *already pending* signal without spinning, the
handler runs exactly once, the mask is restored, the child is still reapable,
and a signal arriving mid-wait also wakes it. Eight checks, all green. The
kernel's half of that contract is now proven rather than assumed, which is what
lets the remaining bug be pursued somewhere else.
Along with it, `rt_sigsuspend` in lib/usys.S -- the syscall existed and the
first-party library simply never exposed it.
On the hang itself: it is not job control, not SMP, not zsh (mksh does it too),
and not any value the kernel returns -- a full syscall trace is in
docs/history/kernel.md section 7, which also records what the contradiction
narrows to. That section had said "root cause not yet isolated" with three
suspects; all three are now eliminated, and the note says what to do next
instead of what to guess.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
One to four processes died per boot with a fault they could not have caused:
`rip 0x0` -- an instruction fetch at zero, which a process does not branch to
-- or a dereference of `0xffffffffffffffea`, which is `-EINVAL`. It hit shells
and schinitd alike and had been carried for a long time as "zsh sometimes jumps
into .data".
`syscall_entry` has to swap FS_BASE from the user's TLS to the kernel's before
it can touch any `%fs:` data, and `wrmsr` destroys rax, rcx and rdx. Those have
to be parked somewhere first -- not on the user stack, which is untrusted and
has not been switched away from yet. They were parked in three globals:
// Single-CPU scratch for syscall_entry FS swap
// (safe while IF cleared by SYSCALL/SFMASK)
uint64 _sc_rax, _sc_rcx, _sc_rdx;
IF being clear answers for an interrupt arriving on *this* CPU. It says nothing
whatever about a second CPU executing the same three stores at the same
instant, and with more than one processor entering syscalls that is not a rare
interleaving -- it is the ordinary one.
**%rcx is the user return address.** SYSCALL puts the user's rip there and
SYSRET takes it back from there. So the CPU that lost the race returned its
process into *another process's* instruction stream, with %rax -- the syscall
number on the way in, the return value on the way out -- swapped alongside it.
Both symptoms fall straight out of that: a zero handed over and followed, and
an errno used as a pointer.
Per-CPU words at %gs:32..48 now. %gs is usable there, before the FS swap, for
exactly the reason RESTORE_KERNEL_FS can already read %gs:0: GS base is per-CPU
in hardware, seginit() sets it once, and userspace cannot change it --
sys_arch_prctl() implements ARCH_SET_FS and ARCH_GET_FS and rejects the rest.
Measured rather than argued. Both variants built once, `build/esp` saved for
each, the same pristine schfs.img restored before every boot, -smp 4:
three globals 10 boots 10 faults, in five of the ten
three per-CPU 18 boots 0 faults
A _Static_assert pins all seven per-CPU offsets, because trapasm.S spells them
as literals and cannot include a header -- a slot that moves would leave a
register quietly holding somebody else's value, which is the hardest possible
thing to find.
**This is the second bug of this exact shape in this file.** The first was
`kernel_fs_base`, a single global every CPU wrote during its own seginit(), so
the last writer won and every CPU restored one CPU's per-CPU block;
RESTORE_KERNEL_FS reads %gs:0 for that reason. The lesson generalises and is
now written down in both places: **on the entry path, a global is a bug.**
Closes the row added to Gate 0 four commits ago. It was the right row to put
first -- a compositor built on this would have failed in ways indistinguishable
from its own bugs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The register steers everything and it had drifted. The text-layer row said the
console still indexes font_data[256][16]; it has not for three commits. Half of
that row is closed -- the console draws real TrueType through font_ops -- and
the half that is not (deleting the cell grid) is now its own item rather than
hiding behind the finished one.
The font-from-disk row is restated rather than closed: the typeface is linked
into the kernel on purpose, because a panic during boot has to be readable, so
what is open is a *replaceable* font and not having one at all.
And Gate 0 gains the row it most needs. User processes are corrupted on SMP --
zero faults across three boots at -smp 1, one/three/one at -smp 2, and it takes
schinitd as well as shells. That is exactly the situation Gate 0 exists to
prevent carrying into the compositor: a desktop built on a kernel that randomly
corrupts processes fails indistinguishably from its own bugs. What has been
ruled out is recorded with it, so the next attempt does not repeat the search.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Guru and SchCotie are gone. Shift is the only mark, and the crash screen draws
it where the face used to be.
Guru was an icon -- a pictogram with a face, denoting one state -- that lived
on the crash screen and nowhere else. Its argument was identity: `:(` is
recognisably Microsoft's, and a crash screen is the single screenshot most
likely to leave the machine, so it is the worst place to be wearing somebody
else's face. That part holds, and it is kept in the branding README because it
is the argument against any second mark. What does not follow is that the
answer is a *new* mark. Shift already signs the system, it is already what the
machine drew on the splash it started with, and a reader who has seen it twice
before the crash recognises it faster than a face they have never seen.
SchCotie was a mascot, and never existed: the file said so itself under "what
this does not cover". A brief for a character nobody is about to draw is not
worth carrying.
So `draw_guru()` and its SVG-space geometry leave panic.c, the two `guru.svg`
files are deleted, and PSOGM calls gfx_draw_logo() -- the same include/logo.h
mask the loader splash and the boot console composite. At its native 128 px:
there is no resampler in the crash path, and the face was scalable in a place
that only ever drew it at one size.
The name stays. "Purple Screen of Guru Meditation" is the Amiga nod, which
panic.c's own header already called out as a separate thing from the mark.
**And taking the screenshot to check it caught a regression from the TTF
console work.** `gfx_draw_char()` -- the pixel-positioned path, which only
PSOGM uses -- still walked `font_data[c][row]` for `row < CHAR_HEIGHT`.
font_data has exactly 16 rows per glyph; CHAR_HEIGHT is the *TrueType* cell
height now, about 21. So every line of the crash report drew five rows of the
next character's bitmap underneath itself, and it looked like each line had
been printed twice. The grid path had been updated when the cell size stopped
being a constant; this one had not, because nothing routine draws text in pixel
coordinates. Both go through one draw_glyph_px() now, and the bitmap's own
geometry is spelled BITMAP_W/BITMAP_H so it cannot be mistaken for a cell size
again.
Two stale claims corrected while in there, in panic.c's header and in
graphics.md: PSOGM has not dimmed-and-floated over the old screen for a while
-- it clears to full purple, and the file's own code comment says why -- and
there is no longer "a face that is obviously a cartoon".
The website's crash section shows the mark in flat white rather than its own
violets, which is what the kernel actually draws: PSOGM composites a coverage
mask in one colour, and those violets sit close enough to #4B1D9A to
half-disappear against it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two notes worth keeping out of the commit log because they are about where to
start next time rather than what changed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Painting every kernel stack at allocation and scanning it on each trap puts the
high-water mark at **3736 of 4096 bytes** -- 91%, in netd, inside lwIP's input
path. 360 bytes of headroom on a kernel that takes interrupts on the current
stack is not headroom: a timer landing at that depth pushes a trapframe and
runs trap() straight off the bottom of the page and into whatever kalloc handed
out next, which is very often another process's kernel stack.
The canary at kstack[0] did not catch this and could not have. It is checked on
trap entry and exit, and a frame allocated in one `sub $N, %rsp` steps clean
over the bottom eight bytes and writes below them without ever touching it. It
catches a slow walk past the end, not one deep call.
8192 now, and the stacks are static -- one per ptable slot, NPROC * KSTACKSIZE
= 1 MB of BSS. Static rather than a bigger kalloc because kalloc() hands out
exactly one page and there is no contiguous multi-page allocator to ask. A
process's slot is fixed for its lifetime, so the stack belonging to that slot is
the natural answer: no allocation to fail, no free to forget, and the kalloc
failure path in allocproc() goes away with it. The page was being paid for out
of kalloc before, one at a time, and undercounted.
**And the AP scheduler stack was already wrong.** startothers() did
`stack = kalloc()` for one page and then handed the AP `stack + KSTACKSIZE` as
its stack top. Exactly right for as long as KSTACKSIZE happened to equal
PGSIZE, and a whole page past the allocation the moment it did not -- which
this commit would have made true. That is not a throwaway boot stack either:
the AP runs mpmain() and then scheduler() on it for the rest of the machine's
life, and takes interrupts on it whenever no process is current. Static too,
NCPU of them.
**This does not fix the intermittent zsh crash**, and the measurement above was
taken while looking for it. It is worth saying plainly: 1-3 shells per boot
still die, so the hypothesis was wrong and the stack was a separate latent bug
that the search turned up.
What the search did establish is worth more than the guess was:
- **It is SMP-only.** Three boots at -smp 1: zero faults. Three at -smp 2:
one, three, one.
- **It is not only zsh.** schinitd took one too.
- **The faults name their cause if you print enough.** `rip 0x0` is a process
handed a zero and following it, not a process that branched anywhere. And
schinitd's `addr 0xffffffffffffffea` is -22, which is -EINVAL: a call
returned an error and the caller used it as a pointer.
So trap.c dumps registers, segments, and the top of the user stack for a fault
at rip below a page or a faulting address near zero, the way it already did for
a GP fault. Neither of the two facts above was visible from the one-line
report, and both came out of the first dump that included them.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`rename()` refused an existing destination, so write-to-a-temporary-then-rename
-- how every careful program saves a file -- failed on the second save of
anything. zsh's history was the visible case: `.zsh_history.new` accumulated
for ever and the history itself never updated.
An earlier attempt to fix this was reverted after it lost both files, and the
note it left behind blamed HTree slot reuse. That was the wrong suspect.
**sys_rename was removing the old name by hand.** memset a `struct dirent` to
zero and writei() it into the parent directory at the offset dirlookup()
returned. That is the v1 filesystem's on-disk layout, written directly,
bypassing dp->ops entirely. On SchFS a directory is a B-tree with an index over
it -- "the record at that offset" is not a thing, and writing zeroes there
corrupted the directory while leaving the name in the index. Adding a second
removal on top of a corrupting one is how both files disappeared.
Every other caller in the file already used dirunlink(). This one had been
open-coding a filesystem it no longer ran on, and the bug stayed invisible for
as long as nothing asked it to remove two names instead of one.
With that corrected, replacing the destination is the straightforward thing it
should always have been: look it up, refuse if it is a directory, unlink it,
drop its nlink. rename(a, a) returns 0 and touches nothing, per POSIX -- both
names already reach the same file, and removing one to add it back is only
equivalent when nothing else is watching.
The lock discipline is inherited rather than invented, and it is the delicate
part: dp_old and dp_new are frequently the *same* directory reached through two
nameiparent() calls, which is two references to one inode. So no two directory
locks are held at once -- each is locked, used, unlocked before the next -- and
the source inode stays unlocked throughout, held alive by an nlink bump.
Directories are still refused, in both roles: moving one needs the `..` fixup
and the ancestor-loop check that are not written, and replacing one needs them
plus an emptiness test. EISDIR either way.
mv a c -> 0, c has a's contents
mv c b -> 0, b replaced, b has a's contents (this is the fix)
mv b b -> 0, nothing happens
mv nope z -> ENOENT
mv b d/ -> 0, b lands inside d
60 create-and-rename cycles leave one file and 4 KB of disk, not 60. /root
holds .zsh_history and no .zsh_history.new, and a marker written in one boot is
still in the history file on the next.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`∞`, `→`, `≤` and `'` could not be typed. `ą` and `ę` could. That pairing is
the whole diagnosis: KBD_UP was 0xE2 and its neighbours filled 0xE0..0xE9,
which are exactly the UTF-8 lead bytes for three-byte characters. Every
character in U+0800..U+FFFF -- most punctuation, every arrow, every maths
symbol, the whole of CJK -- arrived as a value the console read as an arrow key
and helpfully turned into `ESC [ A`. Two-byte sequences lead with 0xC4 and
nothing claimed 0xC4, so Polish came through and the rest did not.
The chord codes already knew this rule and said so in a comment. The navigation
keys predate them and were never brought in line. Stated once, in kbd.h: a key
produces either a Unicode codepoint or a value above 0x10FFFF, and nothing in
between means anything. KEY_* -> KBD_*, which also settles a silent collision
-- include/input.h defines its own KEY_HOME, KEY_UP and KEY_END as evdev
numbers, and kbd.c includes both headers, so three macros were being quietly
redefined in the one file that used them.
Then the layouts, which is what the codepoint-sized keycodes were for.
kernel/dev/keymap.c: us, pl, de. A layout is four tables -- plain, Shift,
AltGr, Shift+AltGr -- of uint32 codepoints. uint32 and not uchar is the reason
the file exists: `ó` fits in a byte and `ą` does not, and half a Polish
alphabet is not a Polish layout.
Two things deliberately are *not* tables:
- **Ctrl is derived from the plain codepoint.** The table it replaces was
indexed by scancode, which quietly assumed US -- on QWERTZ the Y and Z keys
swap, so Ctrl+Z would have suspended a job only on some layouts.
- **Caps Lock is a case toggle on the result**, so AltGr+a with Caps Lock is
`Ą`. No second table could say that, because Caps Lock combines with AltGr
rather than replacing it. Latin Extended-A alternates upper/lower by
codepoint but not all the same way round -- Ł is U+0141 (odd) and Ą is
U+0104 (even) -- so Polish lands in both halves and the parity matters.
kbdgetc() encodes to UTF-8 and returns the bytes one call at a time.
consoleintr()'s contract is bytes: the serial line hands it UTF-8 already and
it could not tell an encoded codepoint from a byte of the same value.
The layouts live in the kernel. Linux's loadkeys compiles a text keymap and
uploads it a key at a time through KDSKBENT, which puts the data in userspace
-- and a machine whose /usr has not mounted then has no layout at all. Here the
kernel always has a working keyboard and `loadkeys` only names which one.
KB_GETLAYOUT/KB_SETLAYOUT/KB_LISTLAYOUT; /etc/vconsole.conf and an
os.schos.keymap job for the boot-time choice. No dead keys, so French and
Spanish are absent rather than wrong.
/etc/locale.conf and LANG=C.UTF-8 in profile and zshenv. Only the charset half
of that is real -- musl decodes UTF-8 whatever the locale says and ships no
locale data -- but an unset LANG reads as "ASCII only" to everything that asks,
which is its own way of producing `?`.
And two symlink bugs found while chasing
zsh: locking failed for /root/.zsh_history: operation not permitted
on every boot. symlink() is the classic atomic lock -- create the link, and if
it exists someone else holds it -- and zsh distinguishes EEXIST ("contended,
retry") from anything else ("this cannot work, give up"). sys_symlink returned
a bare -1, which is -EPERM, so every zsh on the machine took the second branch
on a filesystem that supports symlinks perfectly well. Same errno class as
commit 75ccf98.
The second one the first was hiding: **divesymlink() has been in fs.c since the
fork and nothing ever called it.** A symlink behaved as a small file containing
its own target, so `cat link` printed the target's *name*. open() and openat()
follow the final component now (O_NOFOLLOW gives ELOOP), and stat() and lstat()
stop being the same function, since which one follows is the only difference
between them. Mid-path symlinks are still not resolved -- that belongs in
namex(), which would re-enter lookup holding a directory lock.
Verified on the emulated keyboard, not just over serial: AltGr+a/e/s gives
ąęś, Shift+AltGr gives ĄĘŚ, Caps Lock+AltGr gives ĄĘŚ, de types zy for the
physical y/z keys and @€µ on AltGr. `∞ 'x' → ≤ • — …` typed over serial now
survives. Three fresh boots: 0 lock failures, 0 faults.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Ą Ę Ś Ł Ż" drew as "?????" and the obvious diagnosis -- the font has no
glyphs for them -- was wrong twice over. `struct vtcell.ch` was **one byte**
holding a CP437 index, and the console mapped UTF-8 down to it on the way in.
U+0104 does not fit in a byte. No font could have fixed that; the cell had to
get wider first.
So: `ch` is a uint32 codepoint, the mapping on the way in is gone, and the cell
draws through kernel/dev/ttf.c against JetBrains Mono linked into the image.
Cell size comes from the font's measured advance instead of a hardcoded 8x16.
The grid costs 864 KB of BSS instead of 432 KB, which is the honest price of
holding a codepoint per cell for six terminals at 240x75.
The rasteriser needed three fixes before it could be trusted with this.
**21 KB of locals on a 4 KB kernel stack.** `ttf_render` held an outline (512
points as three arrays) and a raster (1024 edges) as automatics. KSTACKSIZE is
4096. They walked off the bottom of the stack into whatever was underneath,
which surfaced as user processes faulting on addresses they never touched and
then a panic inside freevm() on an overwritten page directory. Nothing pointed
anywhere near a font.
**And then again, recursively.** load_outline() held a 4736-byte outline as a
local *and recursed* for composite glyphs. Composite glyphs are exactly Ą, Ę,
Ś, Ł, Ż -- so the second crash arrived the moment the first fix let Unicode
reach the screen, looking like a fresh bug. Now a static outline per recursion
level with a depth cap of 4 (the font's deepest real nesting is 2), and the
leaf parse split into load_simple() so its 512-byte flag array is not
multiplied by the depth. Worst chain measured from the object file: ~2.3 KB.
Neither showed in tools/ttftest, which has an 8 MB stack. That is the standing
hazard of one source file built for host and kernel: the host is most forgiving
about exactly the resource the kernel is strictest about.
**Component transforms were being skipped**, on the stated theory that a wrong
transform is worse than none. It is not. `‘` in this font is the comma glyph
with a scale of -1 -- a 180-degree rotation -- and the offset that ships with
it only lands correctly after the rotation. Without it the mark went twelve
pixels into a ten-pixel cell and was clipped away entirely, so the character
read as missing from the font rather than as misplaced. F2Dot14 2x2 now, with
SCALED_COMPONENT_OFFSET honoured.
The glyph cache was ASCII-only, so every accented letter re-rasterised on every
repaint: a screenful of Polish did hundreds of bezier flattenings per scroll
where the same screenful of English did none. 95 reserved ASCII slots plus 224
shared slots keyed by codepoint, 64 KB pool. Verified 13680 cached renders
byte-identical to direct ones across collisions and a pool flush.
tools/ttftest speaks UTF-8 now. Iterating bytes meant it could only ever ask
for ASCII, and ASCII is entirely simple glyphs -- it could not reach the code
path that mattered.
Also: resolvconf's success line moves behind /proc/bootmode, same rule as
vgpud. A quiet boot opened with "resolvconf: nameserver 10.0.2.3" where the
one line was supposed to be "Welcome to SchOS!". Failures stay loud.
Verified on screen, not just on the host: Ą Ę Ś Ł Ż ć ń ó ź, Ω λ π Œ Ð Æ ß,
∞ ‘x’ → ≤ all render, panic=0 across four boots.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
vgpud: wanted 7365 KB of DMA memory for a 1920x982 framebuffer
vgpud: not enough contiguous DMA memory
schinitd: restarting os.schos.vgpud (and again, and again, until
schinit: supervisor stopped answering schinit replaced schinitd)
Every number in that diagnostic was about the arena, and the arena had 61 MB
free. The refusal came from do_dma()'s per-request cap, which was 4 MB --
exactly one framebuffer at 1280x800, chosen when that was the only thing
anybody asked for.
virtio-gpu's display size is the size of the **host's window**. Drag it out and
the guest is asked for 1920x982x4 in one contiguous piece, and no amount of
free arena helps. 32 MB now, which is 2560x1600 with room over. The cap is not
there to ration memory -- the arena does that and says so properly -- it is
there so a wild size cannot ask for everything by accident.
DMA_ARENA_BYTES 16 -> 64 MB alongside, for the reason its own comment already
gave and then got the arithmetic wrong on: either side of the handover *both*
drivers hold a framebuffer, so the requirement is two at the largest mode, not
one. 16 MB is two at 1280x800 and nothing bigger. Verified booting at 256M and
512M as well as 1G.
And vgpud no longer dies when it cannot have what it asked for. It claims the
framebuffer before creating the resource, and if the full size cannot be had it
steps down by thirds to 640x480 before giving up -- and gives up with
SCHINIT_EXIT_NORESTART rather than die(), because a driver that will fail
identically on every restart should not be restarted. That loop is what made
schinit replace the supervisor mid-boot.
vgpud: the display is 1920x1080 but only 1280x720 of DMA could be had
is what it says when it steps down. With the cap raised it does not need to:
1920x1080 now allocates its full 8100 KB, 0 restarts.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Three things, all in the first minute of using a shell.
**Arrow keys corrupted the two keystrokes after them.** They arrive as single
keycodes -- KEY_UP is 0xE2 -- and were pushed into the input buffer exactly
like that. No terminal works that way, and 0xE2 is the worst possible byte to
have chosen: it is a UTF-8 lead byte for a three-byte character, so a reader
decoding UTF-8 swallowed the next two keys waiting for continuations that never
arrived. consoleintr() sends the DEC/xterm sequences now -- ESC[A, ESC[D,
ESC[5~ and the rest -- which every terminfo entry and every line editor already
knows. Not echoed: in canonical mode echoing them would move the cursor for
real, which was the other half of what "weird glitches" looked like.
**Then the end of the line vanished as you typed into it**, with the buffer
perfectly correct. One line in vt_putc(): backspace erased the cell it moved
onto. That is a line-discipline erase, not the BS control character -- a
program rubbing a character out sends `\b \b`, and the separation matters
because programs also use plain `\b` to go back. zsh does, on every mid-line
edit:
echo alpha \b\b zha \b\b
back two, rewrite the tail, back two again to park the cursor. Against a
destructive backspace that last pair deleted the `ha` it had just drawn.
`\b` moves and nothing else now, 0x7f is ignored as on a real terminal, and
consputc() spells its own erase out as `\b \b` as it already did for serial.
ESC[@, ESC[P and ESC[X went in alongside, because TERM=linux declares them.
**VT3 to VT6 were blank** because nothing ran on them. NVT is 6 and the kernel
made all six; only two had a shell, so Alt+F3 switched to a terminal that was
working perfectly and had nobody to talk to. Four more manifests.
Six shells starting at once is enough concurrency to expose an intermittent
fault in one of them -- one boot in five, a wild jump into .data that runs
until it writes to 0, which nothing catches because SchOS never sets EFER.NXE.
Three boots with two shells, none. Recorded rather than fixed: it is not caused
by the manifests, only made likelier by them.
Also: QEMU_NET forwards host 8080/8081/8000 to guest 80/8080/8000, so the httpd
is reachable from the machine running QEMU instead of being sealed behind NAT.
Verified end to end. And the greeting prints once again -- a replaced
supervisor was announcing a boot that had already happened.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Ctrl-C killed the shell. consoleread() breaks off the read in progress when
SIGINT arrives and returned -1 to do it -- and -1 is -EPERM by the time it
reaches a program, so every program that handles SIGINT by carrying on saw a
permanent error instead of an interrupted call:
zsh: error on TTY read: operation not permitted
schinitd: restarting os.schos.console-shell
and the next Ctrl-C did it to the replacement. EINTR now, which is what a
signal-interrupted read is required to give. Verified: Ctrl-C an interruptible
command, shell survives, zero restarts.
Same mistake, same file family: link, unlink, rename and renameat returned -1
on every error path. Callers branch on errno -- `if (unlink(p) < 0 && errno !=
ENOENT)` is the standard shape, and against EPERM it always complains -- which
is why zsh reported failures for things that had worked. They return ENOENT,
EEXIST, EXDEV, EISDIR, ENOTEMPTY and EFAULT now. About ninety other `return -1`s
remain in sys_fs.c; these four are done because these four were what a program
tripped over. /dev/mem's unknown minors return ENODEV rather than -1 too.
/dev/urandom was a linear congruential generator seeded with a **constant**, so
every boot produced the same bytes in the same order -- not weak, the same. A
key, a nonce, a temporary filename: shared with every SchOS machine that had
ever run. Seeded at boot from RDRAND where the CPU has it, from the cycle
counter and the wall clock where it does not, and re-stirred per byte. Still an
LCG and still not a CSPRNG; what changed is the part that was dangerous rather
than merely poor.
**Not fixed, and recorded as such:** rename() still will not replace an existing
target, so zsh's history save fails on every exit after the first. An attempt to
unlink the target first was reverted -- the directory is an HTree, dirunlink
followed by dirlink of the same name did not behave, and it panicked in
filewrite with the old file already gone. Losing both files is worse than
refusing, so it refuses until the HTree's slot reuse is understood.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
The arena hands out contiguous memory -- that is the only reason it exists --
so the number that matters is not how much is free but how big the largest
piece is. First fit spends that number cheaply: a 64 KB ring taken from the
middle of a 16 MB arena leaves two 8 MB extents, and a framebuffer wanting 9 MB
then cannot be had on an arena three quarters empty.
dma_alloc() is best fit now: the tightest extent that holds the request, which
leaves the large ones whole for the requests that have no alternative. O(n)
over a table with a handful of entries, and it cannot fragment worse than first
fit for any request.
And the failure says both numbers, because they point at different fixes and
the old message only had one of them:
dma_alloc: no room for 9216000 bytes -- 12591104 free,
largest contiguous piece 8495104 (`schdbg dma` for the map)
"12 MB free" alone reads as out-of-memory on a machine that has plenty; the gap
between the two is the whole story. A fragmented arena is cured by whoever is
holding the block in the middle letting go, a full one by DMA_ARENA_BYTES.
Also fixes a real bug found while reading it: when the extent table was full,
the tail-split path did `continue` while still holding the lock and having
already committed the extent to the caller -- so it carried on scanning, and
could return a second block or fall through to the failure path having handed
one out. It now returns the block it committed, and says so.
**This does not close the report it came from.** vgpud failing to get a
framebuffer was not reproduced here: at 1280x800 the arena has 8.1 MB
contiguous against a 4 MB request. What is fixed is that the next occurrence
explains itself instead of saying "not enough DMA memory" on an empty arena.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
A boot printed about thirty lines before reaching a prompt. Every one was
useful once, and printed on every boot for ever they train the person in front
of the machine to stop reading their own console -- which is expensive on the
day one of them changes.
SchOS UEFI loader
Press F8 for boot options... booting
Welcome to SchOS! (F8 at boot for the full log, or dmesg once you are in)
root@schos / »
**Nothing was deleted, it was routed.** consputc() already wrote to the klog
ring before anywhere else, so a line can be kept in full while being held back
from the two places a person looks. kinfo() is cprintf() with that routing, and
`dmesg` still has the whole boot with timestamps afterwards. The rule for which
is which is not how interesting a line is -- everything was interesting to
somebody once -- but whether you would want to see it on a machine that is
*working*. `pci: 7 devices` is yes the first time and no every time after;
`e1000: no DMA memory for the rings` is yes for ever and stays a cprintf.
The verbose boot the F8 menu already offered now means something much bigger,
which is the other half of this: it is the only way to see any of it live.
Userspace follows through /proc/bootmode, one word. schinit, schinitd and vgpud
hold back their progress lines and never their failures -- a supervisor that
goes quiet when a job dies is worse than one that chatters.
Two things found by testing rather than by reading:
- schinit read /proc/bootmode *before* bootstrap() mounted /proc, so it got
"quiet" every time and the verbose boot was quiet in the one process that
runs first. It reads after the mount now.
- resolvconf announced "already exists; -f to replace it" on every boot after
the first, which is a line about having done nothing. It is quiet when the
file already says what it would have written, and speaks only when the two
disagree -- which means the nameserver changed and the machine is using the
old one.
Verified both ways: quiet boot is six lines, a forced-verbose build prints all
thirty plus the `verbose boot:` steps, and /proc/kmsg holds every line in both.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
`make qemu` gives the machine two display devices, which is deliberate --
stdvga carries the splash and text console, virtio-gpu is what the display
class binds and what a compositor is developed against. What the comment above
QEMU_DISPLAY did not say is that this means **two QEMU displays**, and a window
shows one at a time.
Once vgpud runs they show completely different things: the console and your
shell are on stdvga, and virtio-gpu has whatever vgpud drew, which today is a
test pattern. So a window sitting on the virtio-gpu display shows colour bars
and no prompt, and one that opened before vgpud drew shows black -- and neither
is a failure, though both look exactly like one.
`make qemu-console` boots with one display and no GPU to hand over: vgpud finds
nothing to claim and exits, and the single window is the console. Mostly it is
a way to tell "I am looking at the other screen" apart from "the screen is
broken" in the ten seconds before assuming the second one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Ctrl-C on httpd took the whole machine down:
lwip assert: invalid socket state for recv callback at tcp.c:2024
#1 tcp_recv #2 inet_close #3 sockclose #4 fileclose #5 exit
tcp_listen() does not put a pcb into a listening state -- it frees the
connection pcb and returns a *different, smaller* structure, a
tcp_pcb_listen, which has no recv, sent, err or poll field at all. The two
are different types behind one `struct tcp_pcb *`, and the only callback a
listening one has is accept.
inet_close() cleared the callbacks identically for both, so on a listening
socket tcp_recv() wrote past the end of the allocation. lwIP asserts rather
than allowing that, and an assert here is a panic -- which means any program
that listened and then exited killed the kernel, because the close path runs
from exit(). A user process, ending normally, halting the system.
Nothing had ever done it: until cmd/httpd nothing in the tree listened on TCP
and exited. schdbgd would have found it a few days later.
inet_close() now branches on is->listening -- which was already there, one
field away, and the close path simply never asked. The listening case clears
accept and calls tcp_close (always ERR_OK for a LISTEN pcb, and tcp_abort
would be wrong on one: it reaches for connection state that does not exist).
The connected case also clears `sent`, which it had been leaving set.
Verified: Ctrl-C the listener, no panic, and a second httpd binds port 80
again -- which is the part that proves the pcb was actually freed. Six
requests after the change, all 200.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
`make` had been failing since the e1000 work and I did not see it, because I
was checking build output with `grep error` -- which matches neither "Błąd" nor
mkfs's "image full". Checking the exit status instead found all of this in a
minute.
**usbstick.img was full.** `make ldls-stage` puts a module and its BTF in
sysroot/lib/modules, and a vmlinux BTF is 5 MB on its own; the 16 MB test image
could not hold it. The size cannot move -- tools/windows/bootcheck.ps1 asserts
READ CAPACITY returns exactly 32768 sectors -- so the exclusions grew instead:
lib and usr as well as bin. That image exists to prove the USB driver can read
one block, so its contents were never the point. It also stopped a GPL module
riding into a test artifact, which RAMDISK_EXCLUDE does for the ramdisk and
nothing was doing for this one.
**toybox's httpd was shadowing ours.** /bin/httpd answered `-p` with toybox's
"Unknown option 'p'", because whichever install rule ran second won the name.
TOYBOX_SKIP existed for exactly this and held one entry, `ping`, found the same
hard way. It is now generated from cmd/ -- a list you have to remember is a
list that is wrong the next time cmd/ grows, and it already was: `chvt` had
been silently toybox's, whose VT ioctls are Linux's and not ours.
**ldlsd would not link with clang.** `*out = in;` on a 96-byte struct is a call
to memcpy as far as the C standard is concerned; gcc unrolled it and clang
emitted the call, so a freestanding program linked for months and then did not
on a machine where nothing about it had changed but the compiler. lib/glue.c
now provides memcpy, memmove, memset and memcmp -- the four an implementation
may call without being asked.
**OVMF was never found on NixOS.** `$(dir $(QEMU))share` is the *bin*
directory plus "share", so it looked in /usr/bin/share. The absolute paths
after it covered that up on distributions that keep firmware in /usr; on one
that keeps nothing there it meant the firmware was undiscoverable on a machine
that had it, and the only way to build was to copy the file in by hand. It
resolves the prefix properly now and looks in <prefix>/share/qemu too.
Verified by exit status, from a clean tree and a no-op: both 0. ldls-check
passes 27. The guest boots, serves /srv to the host and answers 403 to
%2e%2e/etc/passwd.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Four complaints, and only one of them was the thing it looked like.
**"toybox is too small."** Half true, and the fix cost no licensing at all:
236 of toybox's applets are what defconfig builds, and the rest live in
toys/pending/ -- awk, bc, diff, more, expr, tr, hexdump, stty among them. Same
0BSD tarball, switched off by a config default. 26 of them are on now, 236 ->
268. Not everything: strace wants ptrace, syslogd wants BSD's facilitynames[],
git wants OpenSSL, and those three break the link.
The toybox build also works again on this machine. Its scripts start
#!/bin/bash, which does not exist on NixOS, so the binary in the tree was one
nobody could reproduce; the shebangs are rewritten to /usr/bin/env bash on the
way in. Pending applets are enabled by editing .config directly, because
`make oldconfig` is the obvious way and undoes it -- every pending symbol is
`default n`.
**BusyBox was asked for and is not here.** It is GPL-2.0-only, and `make
ramroot` links the root image *into the kernel binary*, so it would put GPLv2
inside an Apache-2.0 executable -- which is the exact case ports/Makefile's
NOTPORTS filter and docs/licensing.md §4 exist for. nano is the same answer one
version later. Both recorded in licensing.md with what was done instead, since
"no" without an alternative is how a rule gets quietly broken later.
**An editor that is not vi.** kilo, BSD-2-Clause, one 1300-line file, no
dependencies beyond termios and TIOCGWINSZ, both of which zsh already needed.
Installed as /bin/edit as well as /bin/kilo, because somebody with a file to
fix will type `edit`.
**"wget doesn't work."** Not a userland problem, and BusyBox's wget would have
failed identically: nothing on this system could turn a name into an address,
so every program taking a hostname failed in its own way and each looked like
a separate bug. There is still no DNS client in SchOS and there does not need
to be -- musl has a complete resolver and it works over ordinary UDP sockets.
The one missing fact was which nameserver, which the kernel has had all along
from DHCP and never published. /proc/resolv.conf publishes it in resolv.conf's
exact syntax; cmd/resolvconf decides whether it becomes /etc/resolv.conf, and
will not overwrite a hand-written one without -f.
# wget -O - http://example.com/ | head -1
<!doctype html><html lang="en"><head><title>Example Domain</title>
**Something to host with.** cmd/httpd: GET and HEAD, static files, index.html
for a directory and a listing otherwise, a child per connection. No CGI, no
keep-alive, no TLS, no config file. The path check is the only
security-relevant code in it and it refuses rather than normalises -- no
component may be `..`, and percent-decoding happens first, because %2e%2e is
`..` and a check before decoding does not see it. Both forms answer 403.
And the disk is 100 MB, from 32. It is sparse, so the image is 21 MB on the
host. RAMDISK_BLOCKS went 6000 -> 8000 with it: the ramdisk was at 86% and the
next thing added would have broken `make ramroot`, which nobody would have
noticed until they used it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
schdbgd bridges TCP to the debugger, which is the one way in that does not
need you to be sitting at the machine. It is a bridge and nothing else: a line
in becomes a line written to /dev/dbgro and the answer comes back, so `nc` is a
complete client and there is no clever client to be broken on the day you need
this.
# schdbgd &
schdbgd: debugger on port 4444, loopback only
$ nc 127.0.0.1 4444
dma
arena 0xffff80003da41000-0xffff80003ea41000 16384 KB total, ...
A kernel debugger plus a TCP socket is a remote root hole, so three things were
decided rather than discovered:
- It does not start by itself. schdbgd.job ships Disabled. SchOS has no
kernel command line, so the boot flag the plan asked for is the job
manifest, which is the same thing in this system's own idiom.
- It binds loopback; -a names an address and says so in a paragraph.
- It cannot reach a view that changes state, enforced in the kernel.
That last one is /dev/dbgro: /dev/dbg on minor 1. The minor is the one piece of
per-open state a character device already sees, so which node you opened is the
permission -- nothing to latch, nothing to remember between the write and the
read, no way across. Which views are refused comes from dbg_register_rw() on
the registration itself, because a central list of dangerous views goes stale
in the direction where a new view is quietly treated as safe. Today that is
`watch <addr>`; `watch` with no argument is still the listing and still
answered.
Also: socket() now accepts IPPROTO_TCP with SOCK_STREAM and IPPROTO_UDP with
SOCK_DGRAM. They name the default rather than departing from it, and toybox's
nc writes them out -- so TCP was "Protocol not supported" on a system whose
whole network is TCP.
docs/plan/debugger.md retires into docs/architecture/debugging.md; 16 files
repointed. Every plan in docs/plan/ that was open is now closed, so the next
thing is Gate 0 itself: the survey, with the instrument built.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
e1000 -- Linux's, unmodified -- probes, opens, gets an address by DHCP and
carries ping traffic in a SchOS process. The kernel was driving that NIC and
gave it up, which makes it the first real handover as well as the second
driver.
None of what it needed was a missing feature. Every one was a call that
succeeded, returned zero and did nothing:
_find_next_bit "bit 0 is set" -- for_each_cpu never ended
netif_carrier_off carrier already up -- TCTL.EN never set
__x86_indirect_thunk_r8 the jump discarded -- 255 rx buffers, none made
dma_map_page_attrs bus address 0 -- NIC aimed at physical 0
so the rule from memcpy is now general: a stub returning zero is unsafe
wherever zero is a meaningful answer.
The loader grew ko_fixup_percpu(). The stack guard turned out to be one
per-CPU variable among several; `current` cannot be defused because the driver
dereferences it. Taking the %gs off instead leaves the same opcode reading the
same width from storage the host supplies -- a per-CPU variable in a
single-threaded host is just a variable. Eight bytes become seven and a nop,
and the displacement is not always last, so there is now just enough of an x86
decoder in ko.c to know how long the instruction is.
ldls/kpi/thunk.c is fifteen lines of assembly and the highest-value file here:
retpolines are control flow, and a stub cannot stand in for a jump.
The kernel side:
- ioperm.c, the TSS I/O permission bitmap. A driver's outl is an instruction,
not a call, and e1000's reset path picks it deliberately. IOPL=3 would hand
over the PIC and the disk with it, so it is per-port. Writing it found that
the I/O map base had been written at offset 64 rather than 102, leaving the
CPU checking ports 0-831 against the TSS's own RSP0.
- claim masks the device's IRQ line: 450,000 a second, otherwise.
- net_detach(), the missing half of net_attach_late(). An interface left in
the stack keeps its route and sends every frame to a driver that refuses
it, which looks exactly like a userspace driver that does not work.
- e1000_release() gives up the interface, not just the hardware.
8139too still passes 4/4; ldls-check still passes 27; four CPUs, no panic.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
L4 was listed as "free -- H2 built all of this" and never actually tested,
which is a claim rather than a result. Tested now, and it holds:
ldlsd running ping 2/2; holds index 7 and DMA slots 3 and 4
killed interface DOWN, device released, bus mastering
cleared, DMA reclaimed -- back to vgpud's 3 blocks
ping fails honestly: sendto: -5
a second ldlsd ping 3/3, and the arena hands back the same addresses
pciuser_release_all() and netuser_release_all() sit beside each other in
exit() for the same reason, and that they apply unchanged to a foreign driver
is the whole point of having built them against our own.
With that, every milestone on ldls.md is done, so it leaves docs/plan/ for
docs/architecture/ -- the rule docs/plan/README.md states and the one that
keeps the two directories meaning different things. The new document describes
what is, not what was planned: the five rules, the four pieces, what it costs
(polling, no stack protector, locks that are no-ops), that it can be killed,
and a "what it does not do" that leads with one driver, one kernel version,
tried once.
Sixteen source files pointed at docs/plan/ldls.md and would have been dangling
the moment it moved. All repointed, and the milestone references -- which the
architecture doc deliberately does not have -- rewritten to name sections
instead, so a reader lands somewhere real.
The register row closes with it. hybrid.md freed a slot, ldls.md took it, and
it is now free again.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md L3d, and with it L3 -- the milestone the plan calls the one
that proves the whole idea and the one that cannot be skipped.
# ldlsd /lib/modules/8139too.ko /lib/modules/btf &
kpi: the driver read a MAC off the hardware: 52:54:00🆎cd:ef
ndo_open returned 0
carrying frames. the interface is ldls0.
# cat /proc/netif
interface ldls0 state up address 10.9.0.15 gateway 10.9.0.2
# ping 10.9.0.2 4
64 bytes from 10.9.0.2: icmp_seq=1 time=30 ms
64 bytes from 10.9.0.2: icmp_seq=2 time=20 ms
64 bytes from 10.9.0.2: icmp_seq=3 time=20 ms
64 bytes from 10.9.0.2: icmp_seq=4 time=20 ms
10.9.0.0/24 is reachable only through ldls0, and ldls0 is 8139too running in a
SchOS process. The address was obtained by DHCP over the same driver first.
lwIP -> netdev_ops -> /dev/netdev -> ldlsd -> ndo_start_xmit -> a BAR mapped by
/dev/pci -> the wire, and the whole way back. Nothing in the kernel knows a
Linux driver is involved; nothing in the driver knows it is not in Linux.
It polls rather than taking interrupts. /dev/pci delivers them by blocking
read(), which needs a thread this program does not have, so the driver's NAPI
poll is called from a loop instead -- the same work in a context LDLS can
provide, at the cost of latency and a spinning process.
Four things Linux's alloc_etherdev does that allocating does not, each found by
the driver faulting on it: dev->dev_addr is a pointer aimed at perm_addr;
dev->mc and dev->uc are list heads and are empty only when they point at
themselves; dev->_tx is an array of netdev_queue, because netif_start_queue
clears a bit in _tx[0].state; and __LINK_STATE_START is set by dev_open before
ndo_open is called.
Two did not announce themselves, and they are the ones worth recording.
netif_running(dev) gates 8139too's receive loop. Without it the chip received
the frame, the driver acknowledged the interrupt and left the loop, and nothing
came out -- while every counter said packets were arriving. Found by reading
the chip's own CBR register through the BAR and seeing the hardware had written
600 bytes the driver never collected.
memcpy was still a logging stub. The driver copied each frame into its sk_buff,
the copy did not happen, and the stack was handed exactly the right length of
zeroes; DHCP never completed and nothing reported an error. A stub that returns
zero is not safe for a function whose whole job is a side effect, and the
memory primitives are the worst case because they fail silently and plausibly.
ldls/kpi/string.c exists because of it.
Still one driver, one kernel version, tried once, against an emulated card --
which is what the plan has always promised and is worth repeating next to a
working ping.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md milestone L3c. ldls/kpi/ implements 41 of 8139too's 94
symbols rather than logging them: register access to a mapped BAR, the PCI
calls to /dev/pci, allocation to mmap and PCIIOC_DMA, register_netdev to
/dev/netdev.
# ldlsd /lib/modules/8139too.ko /lib/modules/btf
found 10ec:8139 at 00:05.0
bar 1 0x0000000081060000 256 mem
calling probe, with 41 of 94 symbols implemented
kpi: mapped BAR 1 -- phys 0x0000000081060000, 256 bytes
kpi: the driver read a MAC off the hardware: 52:54:00🆎cd:ef
netuser: ldls0 is a process now, 52:54:0🆎cd:ef
probe returned 0 after 0 stub call(s)
52:54:00🆎cd:ef is what the machine was configured with. Nothing invented
it: the driver bit-banged the card's EEPROM, serially, through a BAR mapped by
/dev/pci, and handed back what it found. That it matches means the loader, the
relocations, the BTF offsets, the BAR mapping and the register accessors are
all correct at once, which is why it was the thing to aim at. Zero stub calls:
every symbol probe reaches is implemented.
Two bugs, one of them the kernel's.
Mine first: pci_iomap checked a failed mmap for -1 only, while SchOS returns
-errno. It returned -13 as a pointer, the driver took that as its register
base, and the first write landed at 0x4e -- thirteen below where it meant to
be.
Underneath it, the real one. sys_mmap rounds a length up to a page, the only
granularity an MMU has, and pciuser_mmio_ok() compared that against the BAR's
own size. rtl8139's registers are 256 bytes, the request became 4096, and the
answer was -EACCES for a device the process legitimately held. A BAR smaller
than a page could never be mapped at all, and nothing had noticed because the
only consumer until now was virtio-gpu, whose BARs are large. The check is now
against the pages the BAR lies in, and the widening is named where it happens:
a sub-page BAR hands over the whole page, forced by the hardware rather than
chosen.
That is exactly what hybrid.md said a foreign driver would be good for --
"what it asks for is what a foreign driver would ask for too" -- arriving as a
concrete bug rather than a prediction.
kpi_io_ok() now bounds every ioread/iowrite against the mapping pci_iomap
returned. A stray access would otherwise be a page fault with no context, and
with no IOMMU a hosted driver's wild writes have to be caught early or not at
all. It is also what turned the fault above into two lines naming the offsets.
Not done, and said so in the output rather than only in the doc: no frame has
moved. ndo_open is never called and there is no transmit or receive path, so
ldlsd releases the interface instead of leaving it up -- a link that reports
itself up with nothing draining its queue is a black hole, and the stack would
send DHCP into it for ever. Down is the true answer until packets move. That
is L3d, now listed separately.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md milestone L3b. ldls/ko.c, btf.c and stub.c were written
freestanding so they would build unchanged on both sides; cmd/ldlsd collects
that promise -- the same three files, linked against lib/ instead of a libc,
in an ordinary SchOS process.
# ldlsd /lib/modules/8139too.ko /lib/modules/btf
module 8139too license GPL wants 94 symbols
defused 6 %gs stack-guard reference(s)
calling init_module
1 _printk(...)
| 8139too: 8139too Fast Ethernet driver 0.9.28
2 __pci_register_driver(...)
btf 122279 types
layout pci_driver.probe +16 pci_dev 2680 bytes
driver "8139too" devices it claims: 10ec:8139 ... and 18 more
calling probe
1 alloc_etherdev_mqs(0x368, 0x1)
probe returned -12 after 1 stub call(s)
Byte for byte the host harness's behaviour, which is what the shared source
was for. Two earlier predictions came good with no work: a process's mmap area
starts at 0x40000000, inside the window R_X86_64_32S needs, and the kernel
never sets EFER.NXE so every mapping is executable. The second is a gap rather
than a feature and is now recorded as one -- LDLS is relying on the absence of
a protection an OS should have.
One thing did not just work. The first run faulted before probe's first call,
err 5 -- present, read, user -- at a kernel address, with the rip resolving to
mov %gs:0x0(%rip),%rax # rtl8139_init_one+0x26
Modules are built -mstack-protector-guard-reg=gs, so the canary comes through
the GS segment, and that is an ABI between the kernel and its own per-CPU area
which a host that is not that kernel cannot provide. ko_defuse_gs() rewrites
those references to xor %reg,%reg.
There are two forms and the second is easy to miss: the prologue loads the
guard with mov (8b) and the epilogue compares it with sub (2b) before a jne to
__stack_chk_fail. xor is right for both -- it zeroes the saved canary and sets
ZF, so the epilogue's branch falls through exactly as a passing check does. Six
sites in 8139too.
It checks every site before patching any and refuses the whole operation on
anything it does not recognise. That refusal is what found the sub form, by
declining to guess -- a loader that half-understands an instruction should not
be editing it.
make ldls-stage/ldls-unstage put a module and its kernel's BTF into the local
sysroot and take them out again. Not part of `all`, and .gitignore refuses
*.ko, so an image only carries somebody else's GPL code between two commands
you typed on purpose.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md L3a -- the class bridge, and the first of the three pieces
L3 turned out to be.
/dev/netdev is /dev/pci with the arrows reversed. That hands a device to a
process; this lets a process be one. The kernel side is netdev_ops and nothing
else -- transmit, receive, mac, link_up, the same four entries e1000
publishes -- so a process claims the device, supplies a MAC, and from then on
read() gives it frames the stack wants sent and write() hands it frames that
arrived.
cmd/netecho proves it and is deliberately not a driver: no hardware, none
claimed, every frame answered by the program itself. DHCP so the interface
gets an address at all, ARP so the stack can find it, ICMP so it can be
pinged. All built by hand from RFCs 826, 791, 792 and 2131.
# netecho &
netuser: ldls0 is a process now, 2:4c:44:4c:53:1
netecho: I am 10.9.0.1 and will offer 10.9.0.2
netecho: answered DHCP, offering an address
# cat /proc/netif
interface ldls0 driver netuser address 10.9.0.2 gateway 10.9.0.1
# ping 10.9.0.1 3
netecho: answered an ARP
netecho: answered a ping
3 packets transmitted, 3 received, 0% packet loss
The interface got its address by DHCP from a process and then answered ping
from one. lwIP never learns that the thing behind netdev_ops is not a driver,
which is the whole property the bridge exists to have.
It dies the way it should, too. kill the process and link_up() answers false
immediately, so the stack refuses to send -- "ping: sendto: -5" -- rather than
swallowing packets into a driver that is not there. Start another and the
*same* interface comes back, keeping its address. That came free:
netuser_release_all() sits beside pciuser_release_all() in exit() for exactly
the same reason, and the reason is that a process holding a device is one that
may crash.
One thing the kernel needed: netinit() starts DHCP on the devices that exist
when it runs, so an interface created later -- which is how an LDLS-hosted
driver arrives -- would have come up with no address and no way to get one.
net_attach_late() fixes that, and lives in kernel/net/net.c because that is
the only file allowed to include lwIP's headers.
Recorded as not done, because it is not: this proves the bridge, not a driver.
Nothing in that test loads a module. That is why it was done first -- if ping
had not worked here the bridge would be wrong, and now a failure with a real
driver can only be the driver's side. L3b is the SchOS-side host, L3c is the
fifteen symbols for real, and L3 is the two joined.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md milestone L2, less the half that needs /dev/pci.
In Linux, __pci_register_driver ends at the PCI core, which matches a
driver's id_table against the bus and calls probe(). There is no PCI core
here, so LDLS keeps the pointer that call was given and plays the part.
To do that it must know where pci_driver.probe is, and it asks the kernel
rather than being told by us. ldls/btf.c reads /sys/kernel/btf/vmlinux --
122,279 types, every struct layout and every function prototype, as generated
data describing the kernel that is installed. Implemented from
Documentation/bpf/btf.rst, which is a published specification.
$ ldls-types /sys/kernel/btf/vmlinux --need
pci_driver probe offset 16 size 8
pci_dev resource offset 1000 size 1088
resource start offset 0 size 8
all present
Cross-checked against pahole on the same file, field for field. No offset in
this is ours, which is rule 3's uncomfortable row disappearing rather than
being argued about.
And then the driver:
driver name "8139too"
devices it claims: 10ec:8139 ... and 16 more
calling probe(pci_dev 10ec:8139, ...)
1 alloc_etherdev_mqs(0x368, 1, 1)
2 pci_enable_device / 3 pci_request_regions / 4 pci_set_master
5 pci_iomap(pdev, 1, 0)
6..544 ioread8 / iowrite8 -- 0x88, 0x8a, 0x8c, 0x8e, over and over
545 dev_addr_mod / 547 netif_napi_add_weight_locked
549 timer_init_key / 550 register_netdev / 551 netdev_info
probe returned 0 after 552 stub call(s)
10ec:8139 is the real RTL8139 id. It mapped BAR 1, the one marked
IORESOURCE_MEM. Those 538 alternating byte accesses stepping 0x88/0x8a/0x8c/
0x8e are serial EEPROM clocking -- the driver bit-banging the chip for its MAC
address and handing the result to dev_addr_mod. Then NAPI, a watchdog timer,
register_netdev, its "found it" line, and zero.
Fifteen distinct symbols carry that entire probe, and three of them are 540 of
the 552 calls. L1 said 44 symbols carry 110 modules through init; L2 says 15
carry this one through probe. Neither is a number anyone would have guessed
and both came from running the thing.
Recorded as not done, because it is not: probe receives a pci_dev whose shape
is right and whose contents are invented. The BARs are made up, pci_iomap
returns a zeroed page, and 8139too read a MAC address of zeroes and was
perfectly happy about it. The "all through /dev/pci" half of L2 belongs to the
SchOS side. Also recorded: BTF has to come from somewhere, and SchOS has no
/sys/kernel/btf/vmlinux -- the user brings it with the module, from the kernel
the module was built for.
make ldls-check is 27 checks, four of them L2's, and it says so out loud when
it skips them on a machine with no BTF rather than passing silently.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Counting stub calls turned out to be the wrong metric -- one module walking an
rbtree called rb_first sixty-four times and told us nothing. Counting how many
*modules* need a symbol is the useful one:
__kmem_cache_create_args 25
crypto_register_template 11
_printk 10
crypto_register_alg 10
__register_nls 9
...
Forty-four distinct symbols carry all 110 modules through init_module. Small
enough to be a plan rather than an estimate, and not a number anyone could
have guessed: the slab allocator at the top and a long tail of registration
calls that mostly want to record a pointer and return zero.
It says nothing about probe(), which is where the real surface is and which
the kernel rather than the module is supposed to call. That is L2.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
docs/plan/ldls.md milestone L1. Every undefined symbol resolves to a
trampoline -- twenty generated bytes that load the symbol's index and jump to
a shared thunk, which saves the argument registers and reports the call. Then
init_module is simply called.
$ ldls-run 8139too.ko
module 8139too
license GPL
wants 94 symbols
calling init_module at 0x416fc020
1 _printk(0x416fb6c0, 0, 0)
| 8139too: 8139too Fast Ethernet driver 0.9.28
2 __pci_register_driver(0x416fb400, 0x416fff80, 0x416fbdbb)
init_module returned 0 after 2 stub call(s)
That second line is the driver's own banner, printed through a _printk that
is ours, from a string in the module's own .rodata that a relocation put
there. There is no stronger evidence that a load worked than the loaded thing
speaking.
Stubs return zero rather than stopping, which departs from what the milestone
originally said and does so deliberately: stopping at the first call tells you
one name, carrying on tells you the sequence, and the sequence is the thing a
symbol table cannot give you. A driver that then dereferences the zero faults,
and that is a result too -- it says how far it got before it needed the kernel
to have really done something.
The first run failed on neither of those. It failed on a relocation:
ldls-run: relocate: a signed 32-bit relocation does not fit
A module is compiled -mcmodel=kernel, so the compiler emits R_X86_64_32S for
anything it believes lives in the top 2 GB, and an ordinary mmap at 0x7f...
has nowhere to put it. Linux gives modules a region within 2 GB of the kernel
text; the harness uses MAP_32BIT to reach the same window from the other end.
On SchOS this costs nothing -- a process's mmap area starts at 0x40000000 and
is already inside it -- but it is a real constraint on where the host may load
a module, and a loader that did not check its own arithmetic would have found
it much later and much more confusingly.
Swept over 500 stock modules: 449 ran init to completion, 22 faulted on a
stub's zero, 29 have no init_module, and zero hit a loader error.
Recorded honestly in "what it will not do": running init is not working. Every
symbol is a stub, so what has been shown is that drivers ask for things in a
readable order, not that anything answers. Also recorded: every undefined
symbol in a module is NOTYPE, so the stubs cannot tell jiffies from
pci_iomap and both get a trampoline -- BTF distinguishes VAR from FUNC and
that is where the fix belongs rather than in a guess.
make ldls-check is 23 checks now, five of them L1's, all against
ldls/test/refmod.c which is ours and now has an init_module of its own.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Answers the question directly in docs/licensing.md §6, because "LDLS runs
Linux drivers" reads like it contradicts §2 and does not.
LDLS is Apache-2.0. Every file under ldls/ is ours; the loader came from the
ELF-64 gABI and the x86-64 psABI. The licence of LDLS and the licence status
of what happens at run time are two different questions and only the first is
about us:
ldls/ Apache-2.0 distributed by us
a .ko GPL-2.0 distributed by the user's distro
the two in one process -- distributed by nobody
GPLv2 §0 says where its obligations attach -- "the act of running the Program
is not restricted" -- so no combined work is distributed by anyone and no
obligation is triggered. Same position FreeBSD has shipped from for a decade.
Stated honestly in the same section: the *user* cannot redistribute the
combination either, which is why RAMDISK_EXCLUDE exists and why .gitignore
refuses *.ko.
EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL was left open in the plan; it is now answered and the answer
is cleaner than expected. That marking gates *Linux's own* symbols. Every
symbol LDLS provides is ours, reimplemented from facts, so there is no gate
being bypassed because no Linux symbol is being exposed. LDLS implements no
licence check -- it reads the declared licence and prints it before loading
anything.
And the sharpest edge in rule 3 mostly goes away. The uncomfortable row was
struct layouts, which a compiled driver indexes by offset, so the shim must
reproduce them exactly -- and a field-for-field match looks like transcription
even when it is not. It does not have to be in our source: kernels built with
CONFIG_DEBUG_INFO_BTF publish /sys/kernel/btf/vmlinux, and that carries both
the layouts and the function prototypes as generated type data about the
kernel the user already has. Verified on this machine: struct pci_dev field by
field, and FUNC 'pci_iomap' with its FUNC_PROTO. LDLS reads them at load time
on the user's machine; our source contains neither.
That also mostly dissolves rule 4, since BTF describes the kernel that is
actually installed rather than one pinned by guessing. What BTF does not give
is behaviour -- what napi_complete_done *does* is still ours to write from
documentation, and that is the whole of the real work.
Also adds the SPDX header ldls/ko.h was missing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VQ7Qx8E1q1M1bbCq8QLHS2
Nexoniarz